An environmental engineering exercise from Science Buddies

TOO DARN HOT!: In this activity, you'll find you can beat the heat with a change of color. Image: George Retseck

• Neutrino Hunters

Key concepts
Light
Energy
Heat
Colors
Absorption
Reflectivity

Introduction
Have you ever wondered if changing the color of your house does anything other than alter its appearance? Could it also be doing something as practical as influencing how much money is spent on energy bills? On hot summer days, people consume a lot of energy to keep their houses cool. If less energy could be used to do this, not only would it save people money, it might also help the environment by decreasing the amount of energy we use! In this activity, you will test which colors may keep a house from getting quite as hot. Maybe you'll even find a good color to repaint your home!

Background
How does the color of your house affect the temperature inside? To answer this question, think about the clothes that you would wear on a hot, sunny day. Would you rather wear a light-colored shirt or a dark one? You'd probably get much warmer in a dark shirt compared with a light one. This is because the lighter shirt reflects more light than the darker one, which absorbs much more light, or energy, warming up the shirt. It then transfers the heat to your body, warming you more than the light-colored shirt would. The house color works on the same principle.

Materials
•    Black, white and gray construction paper
•    Scissors
•    Three cardboard boxes, all the same size.  For example, this could be three shoe boxes or three cereal boxes
•    Rubber cement
•    Thermometer
•    A sunny spot outside on a hot day

Preparation
•    Carefully cut the white construction paper into pieces so that it can cover the entire surface of one of the cardboard boxes.
•    Use the rubber cement to attach the paper to the box, attaching the paper as smoothly as possible so that there are no air pockets between the paper and the box below it.
•    Just as you did with the white box, attach the gray and black construction paper, cementing each color on one of the other two boxes. You should now have a white box, a gray box, and a black box.

Procedure
•    Put the thermometer in the white box, close it, and take it outside.
•    Place the white box in the sunny spot you picked. Leave it there for 30 minutes.
•    After 30 minutes, open the box and quickly read the temperature on the thermometer. How hot was it inside the box?
•    Put the thermometer in the shade somewhere near the box (still outside). After it has adjusted to the shade, read the temperature. How hot was it in the shade?
•    Repeat these steps with the gray and black boxes, separately. How hot was it inside the gray and black boxes after 30 minutes? How did the temperature in the boxes compare with the temperature in the shade nearby?
•    Which box was the hottest after 30 minutes, and which was the coolest? How did their temperatures compare with the temperatures in the shade?
•    Tip: Try to test all three boxes in the same cloud conditions. For example, try to test them all when it is sunny for the 30 minutes or test them all when it is partly cloudy for the 30 minutes. If cloud conditions change while testing one of the boxes, try retesting it again later during similar conditions.
•    Extra: How does a house's color affect how warm it stays during the winter? You can investigate this by repeating this activity but this time test the boxes on top of a tray of ice (covered with a white plastic bag to keep the boxes dry). Which color box stays the warmest in winterlike conditions?
•    Extra: What about colors other than black, white and gray? To more closely mimic a real house you can repeat this activity, but instead of using construction paper, paint the boxes different colors. Most major paint manufacturers can tell you the light reflectance value (LRV) of any color paint. For example, white usually reflects 80 percent of the light that shines on it whereas for black it is 5 percent. Conduct your test for a series of colors with different LRV values. How does the temperature change with the paint color's LRV?
•    Extra: House color is only one aspect of house design. Does the material you choose on the outside of your house make a difference? In this activity you used a box wrapped in paper material to simulate a painted house. What about real materials used to cover houses? Try this activity again using different materials: adobe, stucco, wood, siding, metal, etcetera. Do some materials keep the house cooler than others in hot weather?

View
1. 1. promytius 11:27 AM 7/26/12

Nice try. Too many other factors to really determine if color has a noticeable effect. Materials, location (both global and local), nearby flora, water, rocks, roads, winds, etc., etc. all can contribute to house temperature; but again, a great way to introduce and investigate a science question. Thanks.

2. 2. InquiringConstructivist 11:59 AM 7/26/12

I have seen this taught to students and taught something like this for years, and have considered it deeply while consulting for EnergyTeachers.org.
There are many unwritten assumptions taken here, so this study should also include an explicit enumeration of them. One the students should consider is shading. If the house/shirt is completely unshaded, all stated in the article is true, but if it is shaded, then maybe black is better, depending on the temperature of surrounding objects in the shade.
Also, there are various blacks and whites with differing emissivities in infrared, which could be quite important for cooling.
In short, there are more interactions than just sun>body/house, and an activity should be open-ended so the "buddy" can explore more instead of just getting the rote (and in a few limited cases wrong, although usually right) answer that white is better.

3. 3. jerryd 03:27 PM 7/26/12

Before one does anything one has to consider the site. In some areas like Fla, etc, south, a white roof would be great, in others like Minnesota, not so much.

I live in Fla and only using 1'' of urethane foam and galvanized roofing only had a \$30 electric bill last month. But I bought under an old oak forest and run both A/C and fans plus eff appliances. Though it does include charging my EV's too, my only transport.

I'm moving and juat 1kw of PV handles both my A/C and other needs on my 32' sailboat including it's motor power. Saving energy cam be both profitable and fun if you do it right.

4. 4. pannaksero 04:45 AM 8/5/13

Nice tips I would never think of that!

To lower my extremelly high bills I used Tower Utility to compare prices. At first I thought that there is no way to find good deal on a website which compare suppliers but now my bills are lower. And they can offer you special deal for business and that's a huge advantage for me.

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.

More from Scientific American

• @ScientificAmerican | 5 hours ago

Can We Harness Disruption to Improve Our World's Future?

• News | 5 hours ago

Federal Flood Maps Left New York Unprepared for Sandy, and FEMA Knew It

• News | 7 hours ago

Smart Wig Could Compete with Google Glass

• News | 8 hours ago | 1

Will to Persevere Can Be Triggered by Electric Stimulation

• Climatewire | 10 hours ago | 5

More »

Latest from SA Blog Network

• Wonderful Things: The Pugnacious, Alien-esque Skeleton Shrimp

The Artful Amoeba | 3 hours ago
• Can We Harness Disruption to Improve Our World's Future?

STAFF
@ScientificAmerican | 5 hours ago
• British Storm Brings Up History's First Work of Social Media

Plugged In | 5 hours ago
• Rolling on Wheels That Aren t Round

Observations | 6 hours ago
• The future of nuclear energy: Let a thousand flowers bloom

The Curious Wavefunction | 6 hours ago

Science Jobs of the Week

X

Give a 1 year subscription as low as \$14.99

X

X

Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X