Rock Solid? How Particles Affect Porosity

A geologic challenge from Science Buddies

Science that really rocks: Can you fit any water in a rock? Try this easy at-home activity and the answer might just surprise you. Image: iStockphoto/carebott

• Neutrino Hunters

Key concepts
Geology
Porosity
Rocks
Particles

Introduction
Have you ever heard the expression, "solid as a rock"? As it turns out, rocks are not entirely solid. Rocks actually have tiny pockets of air inside them. This is obvious when you look at a piece of volcanic rock (often called basalt), which is full of visible holes. But dense rocks, such as granite, have tiny air pockets inside them, too. These pockets of air are just much smaller.

If you picked up one volcanic rock as well as one granite rock of the same size, you would notice they don't weigh the same. The granite is heavier than the volcanic rock. The many large holes of air in the latter make it less dense—and more porous—than the granite, which also makes it lighter. Something that has more holes in it is more porous. So "porosity" is one characteristic that can help tell you what kind of rock you have.

Background
Rocks—and most other objects, for that matter—are made up of particles of varying sizes that are packed together. In between the particles are spaces that are filled with gas, air or liquid. Particles' shapes and sizes affect how they aggregate, including how tightly they can pack together, which affects a rock's porosity—a property that is the ratio of the volume of a rock's empty spaces to its total volume.

In general, larger particles cannot pack together as well as smaller particles can, which means that packing larger particles together leaves more space for air to fill between the particles. You can imagine this if you have one cup full of marbles and another cup full of sand. You'll be able to see many more spaces between the marbles than between the grains of sand.

Materials
•    Three clear plastic cups
•    Water
•    Measuring cup
•    Rocks that can be sorted into one of three size groups (ideally all of the same type of rock, such as granite)
•    Screen (optional)

Preparation
•    Make sure that the rocks are sorted into three different groups by size. The greater the difference in size between the rocks is, the easier it'll be to interpret your results. There should be enough of each group of rocks to completely fill a plastic cup.

Procedure
•    Fill each clear plastic cup to the top with one of the groups of rocks. How much space do you see between the rocks in the different cups?
•    Fill the measuring cup with one cup of water.
•    Pour the water into one of the cups of rocks, filling the cup to the top.
•    How much water is left in the measuring cup? Subtracting the amount left in the measuring cup from one cup will tell you how much volume the air between the rocks took up. How much volume did the air take up?
•    To each of the two other cups of rocks, again measure one cup of water, fill each cup of rocks with water, and determine how much volume the air took up.
•    How much air did the cup with the largest rocks have compared with the cup with the smallest rocks? How did the volume of air in those cups compare with the volume of air in the cup with the medium-size rocks?
•    Extra: You can calculate the porosity of each of the cups of different size rocks you used in this activity. To do this, divide the volume of air taken up by each cup of rocks by the total volume of water the cup could hold (without rocks in it). For example, if the air took up one half cup and the cup could hold one cup total, the porosity would be 50 percent. What is the porosity of each of the cups of the different-size rocks?
•    Extra: Soil is a mixture of rocks, minerals and organic matter. Porosity is also a property of soil. Try the same activity using different types of soil: clay, loam, sandy, silty, potting soil, compost, etcetera, but put a screen on top of the cup to keep organic matter from floating out as you pour the water into the cup. Do different types of soils have different porosities?

View
1. 1. stender1 08:12 PM 11/24/12

This article mentions composting. Do any readers here have experience composting sawdust and coffee grounds -- both of which are fine in texture? If so, what other materials do you use in your mixture?

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.

More from Scientific American

• News | 40 minutes ago

Strategies for Aging Vary Widely across 46 Species with Some Scarcely Deteriorating

• Climatewire | 3 hours ago | 1

European Coastal Defenses May Reduce Destruction from Epic Storm

• Scientific American Magazine | 5 hours ago | 6

The Internet Has Become the External Hard Drive for Our Memories

• Scientific American Magazine | 5 hours ago | 4

Protecting Your Data on The Cloud

• Scientific American Mind | 6 hours ago | 3

Figurative Speech Sways Decisions

See what we're tweeting about

More »

Latest from SA Blog Network

• Oh the Horror! Best of the Blogs for November...

Video of the Week | 1 hour ago
• Best of the Blogs for November: Oh the Horror!!

PsiVid | 1 hour ago
• 4 Billion Years of Martian History in 2 Minutes

Life, Unbounded | 2 hours ago
• My Story Collider Story - Working Twice as Hard

The Urban Scientist | 3 hours ago
• Mathematics+Fatherhood: an Interview with Darren Glass

Roots of Unity | 7 hours ago

Science Jobs of the Week

Rock Solid? How Particles Affect Porosity

X

Give a Gift & Get a Gift - Free!

Give a 1 year subscription as low as \$14.99

X

X

Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

Yes, please link my existing account with for quick, secure access.

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X

Institutional Access

It has been identified that the institution you are trying to access this article from has institutional site license access to Scientific American on nature.com. To access this article in its entirety through site license access, click below.

X

X