 helps bumblebees predict where to find the most nectar.)
A flower's electric field (right, with associated electric potential on the left) helps bumblebees predict where to find the most nectar.
Image: Dominic Clarke
-
What a Plant Knows
How does a Venus flytrap know when to snap shut? Can it actually feel an insect’s tiny, spindly legs? And how do cherry blossoms know when to bloom? Can they...
Read More »
As they zero in on their sugary reward, foraging bumblebees follow an invisible clue: electric fields. Although some animals, including sharks, are known to have an electric sense, this is the first time the ability has been documented in insects.
Pollinating insects take in a large number of sensory cues, from colors and fragrances to petal textures and air humidity. Being able to judge which flowers will provide the most nectar, and which have already been plundered by other pollinators, helps them to use their energy more efficiently.
It has long been known that bumblebees build up a positive electrical charge as they rapidly flap their wings; when they land on flowers, this charge helps pollen to stick to their hairs. Daniel Robert, a biologist at the University of Bristol, UK, knew that such electrical interactions would temporarily change the electrical status of the flowers — but he did not know whether bumblebees were picking up on this.
Flower power
Keen to find out, he and a team of colleagues measured the net charges of individuals of Bombus terrestris, a common species of bumblebee, by using sucrose to lure them into a Faraday pail — an electrically shielded bucket that reacts to the charge of anything inside it. As expected, most bumblebees were carrying a positive charge.
Next, the team placed the insects into an arena with petunias (Petunia integrifolia) and measured the flowers' electrical potentials. Sure enough, when the bees landed, the flowers became a little more positively charged.
Finally, the team released bumblebees into an arena with artificial flowers, half of which were positively charged and carried a sucrose reward, and the other half of which were grounded and carried a bitter solution. Over time, the bees increasingly visited the rewarding charged flowers.
But when the researchers turned off the electrical charge on the flowers and re-released the trained bees, the insects visited rewarding flowers only about half of the time, as they would have by random chance. That suggested that the bees were detecting the electric fields and using them to guide their activities, rather than relying on other clues such as fragrance. The team reports its results in this week's Science.
“We think bumblebees are using this ability to perceive electrical fields to determine if flowers were recently visited by other bumblebees and are therefore worth visiting,” says Robert.
“We had no idea that this sense even existed," says Thomas Seeley, a behavioral biologist at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. "Assuming we can replicate the findings, this is going to open up a whole new window on insect sensory systems for us to study.”
Some experts suggest that the study has implications for insects other than bees. “If you think about it, these discoveries could also apply to hoverflies and moths," says Robert Raguso, a chemical ecologist also at Cornell. "We don’t know if they can perceive charge differentials, but they burn a lot of energy while hovering around looking for pollen or nectar. So it would make sense for them to attend to such cues."
This article is reproduced with permission from the magazine Nature. The article was first published on February 21, 2013.
See what we're tweeting about
6 Comments
Add CommentUrgent !!!!!!! Very interesting! I could explain the bees actual decline corelated with the uprise of micro-waves communication that have a wave length arrounnd 1 centimeter (one inch / 2.52) just the same size as bees and many flowers! So flower have an antenna effect and may not seem as appealing at bees as before + it could mix the signals on the bees too!
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisSo I think we should urgently conduct experimentation on that field, basically do bees have more problems near fix antennas ? If so beaming of rural areas should be done only near habitations singling out fields and other part that need pollination!
First time electric sense seen in insects? No. See
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this"Attraction of Ants (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) to Electric Fields" MacKay et al., J. Kansas Entomological Soc., 1992. You can see ants in an ant farm respond to electrodes energized with 1 volt AC....
Did anyone think to measure the charges of real flowers before and after bee visits?
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisThe answer, if you can get the original Science article, is yes. They measured the voltage of the stem of a flower and it goes up by tens of mV in a few seconds and stays above baseline for 100 seconds. Strangely the voltage drops slightly a couple seconds before the bee touches, but I think they ascribe this to capacitative coupling when the bee is close.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisI couldn't understand the experimental design. Does anyone know why those researchers used different reward in order to examine the sense of electrical charge?
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisloved this-- actually, I loved it so much that I featured it in my own post on bees (though my article is more about their 'debates'-- which include head butting and dancing!). Thanks for the awesome content- keep it coming!
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thishttp://incubator.rockefeller.edu/?p=925