Image: LindaYolanda/iStockPhoto
Feelings of hate may be different for those with depression, a new study suggests.
The results show depressed people have abnormalities in the brain's so-called "hate circuit." Normally, brain activity is synchronous across this circuit's three regions. But in depressed patients, activity in these regions is out of sync, said study researcher Jianfeng Feng, a professor in computer studies at the University of Warwick in the United Kingdom.
These differing activity levels, which the researchers referred to as an "uncoupling" of the circuit, may explain why depressed people experience self-loathing, they said. Depressed people may not be able to deal appropriately with feelings of hate, and as a consequence, develop self-hatred and withdraw from social situations, the researchers said.
However, much work is needed to conclusively show that depressed patients do indeed have problems with their hate control that are tied to this brain circuit. Patients in the study were not doing anything in particular while they had their brains scanned, so it's impossible to know what their feelings were at the time. In addition, it's not clear whether the brain abnormalities are a cause or a consequence of depression, Feng told MyHealthNewsDaily.
Brain scans
In the study, researchers scanned the brains of 39 depressed patients and 37 healthy people using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fRMI).The researchers used the scans to create maps of networks in the brain.
They found that the hate circuit— which consists of the superior frontal gyrus, insula and putamen of the brain— was decoupled in depressed patients.
The method used in this study to analyze the brain is exciting, said Angela Laird, an associate professor of radiology at the University of Texas Health Science Center San Antonio. The researchers were attempting to look at the brain's so-called "functional connectivity," that is, interactions between brain regions during the course of a particular task, or at rest, Laird said. This method allows researchers to examine around 100 brain regions, instead of just the eight or 10 regions that could previously be examined, Laird said.
Criticism
However, Laird said she is "less enthusiastic" about the conclusions the researchers drawn from their finding. "They made a very direct connection," between the brain activity patterns they saw and their conclusion that the "hate circuit" is uncoupled.
The hate circuit, which was identified in 2008 by Semir Zeki of University College London, is associated with other tasks, Laird said. In fact, two of the brain regions in the "hate circuit" are also thought to be involved in feelings of love.
Laird said she sees problems with the practice of labeling a set of regions in the brain as a specific circuit, such as the "hate circuit."
This practice "tries to reduce very complex functions associated with a set of very complex brain regions down to a few buzz words," Laird said.
While new technologies have advanced the way we analyze the brain, our methods for interpreting study results have not reached the same level, Laird said.
In their next study, the researchers said they plan to show images to depressed patients of objects or people the patients dislike while their brains are scanned, Feng said.
The study is published today (Oct. 4) in the journal Molecular Psychiatry.
Pass it on: Depressed patients may have problems with the function of a brain circuit thought to be involved in feelings of hate.
- Hypersex to Hoarding: 7 New Psychological Disorders
- Top 10 Stigmatized Health Disorders
- 10 Medical Myths That Just Won’t Go Away
See what we're tweeting about
5 Comments
Add CommentInteresting article but certainly requires more research before any conclusions as to the hate circuit of the brain can be validated. I think unbeliever needs some professional help, he obviously has some hate issues to be worked through. Perhaps he could be part of one of the studies on hatred.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisSome people thrive on attention. It's really best to ignore them and not address them directly. It annoys the hell out of them!
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisIt would be interesting to know more about the specific circuits involved and when they are engaged.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisI wonder if it really is a "hate circuit" per se.
My own thinking is that this may be a triggering of less than optimal early attachment/working models of the mind.
Specifically, that without sufficient emotional acceptance/nurturing to meet fundamental needs early in life that this limits one's own capacity for soothing (and in fact results in self-hate and loathing).
Not to mention some possibility of unaccepted emotions and needs resulting in rage that is turned inwards in a form of self-hate.
Hence, the link to being related to "loving" circuits may indeed be relevant. It's just that the "loving" circuits may not have been sufficiently activated/responded to early in life.
"In fact, two of the brain regions in the "hate circuit" are also thought to be involved in feelings of love."
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisWell this explains my last marriage. A love/hate relationship.
She loved to hate me. I hated myself for loving her.
One has to note that Freud once said, "Depression is anger turned inward". Perhaps we now have proof he was right.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this