EarthTalk is produced by E/The Environmental Magazine. GOT AN ENVIRONMENTAL QUESTION? Send it to: EarthTalk, c/o E/The Environmental Magazine, P.O. Box 5098, Westport, CT 06881; submit it at: www.emagazine.com/earthtalk/thisweek/, or e-mail: earthtalk@emagazine.com. Read past columns at: www.emagazine.com/earthtalk/archives.php.

9 Comments

1. 1. ductileironman 04:29 PM 11/5/08

   Abolish city living!

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

2. 2. silvrhairdevil in reply to ductileironman 08:15 AM 11/6/08

   That seems extreme.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

3. 3. ductileironman in reply to silvrhairdevil 11:47 AM 11/6/08

   I was just emulating the normal kind or response to this stuff.. tongue in cheek. I really don't know how this kind of information is useful beyond individual decision making. My perception with this kind of study is that people take the information presented and try to use it to make others conform to a way of living instead of using it for their own benefit.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

4. 4. Nathaniel 01:34 PM 11/6/08

   A more economically and environmentally friendly way to live would be in several small, close-knit, self-sustaining communities. Good luck convincing people that technology is bad and that we should all live like Quakers though.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

5. 5. silvrhairdevil 11:14 AM 11/8/08

   I've lived in big cities, small cities, villages and out in the country. I feel sorry for inner-city kids who have to depend on planned forays to the country to see what nature is like up close.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

6. 6. debellocivili 12:46 AM 11/10/08

   Sustainable eco-living in cities will be possible once money is abolished, all mouths are fed/watered, and all people concentrate on the higher functions of human brain (creativity, reason, and invention)

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

7. 7. ductileironman in reply to debellocivili 03:28 PM 11/10/08

   if all people concentrate on the higher functions of the human brain to exclusion, we get more of the same!!! it is this constant barrage of intellectual elitism that leads to exactly my point above. People say that we need to abolish all the things that force us to work toward the basics and only concentrate on the things that have no value!!! Abolishment of anything is wrong minded! How about, consider that you cannot get rid of city living, but do all you can to ensure that you do not infringe the ability of others by narrowing their right to choose to live a less metropolitan life and chose a life more exposed to open spaces. To think it is possible to live based upon the better good of all, with no money, no posession, is foolish. The greatest preserver of the wildlife around him is the educated hunter, for he knows that he must give true balance to the wildlife in order that it flourish. Unfortunately, the population of humans in this world is beyond what natural wildlife can sustain, and we are forced to congregate, commit to animal husbandry, raise and protect crop foods and animals for our nourishment, or find a way to extract ourselves completely from the system. It is sad that so many live in large cities where their only exposure to nature is a stroll in the park, where their lives may be endangered by other humans who are so depraved as to take that small space of isolation and use it for evil purposes. Too much exposure to the ills bred in the human mind begets further unrest in the soul. We chose to escape and find ourselves bound further in the grasping hands of media, culture, and so our souls wither. And we begin to find the human condition evil, and we claim that we need to eliminate all that makes humanity evil.
   
   See how out of control this whole thing can get? How about people just accept that it is healthy to withraw from society and commune with nature, but don't try to abolish anything. Maybe I started it, but I want people to really think about it.
   
   All the organizations that have been around to promote this sort of healthy exposure to nature (i.e. boy scouts, girl scouts, etc) have been put under assault by those who see them in one light only, and thus make them a negative stigma to the intellectual elite. Provide your children with true life skills, and a love of nature, and they will preserve the planet. Tell them that they should give up everything for the betterment of all, and you will never teach them the true point behind this article.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

8. 8. skigrl 10:19 AM 11/11/08

   I've read Last Child in the Woods, and have taught for over 30 years. At first I did not 'get' the excitement this book caused among educators. I took students backpacking, I brought them from Michigan out to Yellowstone National Park, I took them outside during lessons whenever I could, and I spent my childhood playing outside in orchards and vacant lots, so the book was old-stuff to me, just that it had brain research supporting what I've known all along.
   Then it hit me: we as a society have gone beyond the tipping point :kids AND their teachers never spend time outside and are nature deficit. The teachers today have never spent time outside themselves. They are indoor computer/techno folks, so to them this is big news. And that is what scares me so much.
   Please don't see this a s a put-down of technology. We need both--and we need to teach kids that nature is real, is important. We need to get them outside in it for free activities. Most kids, if they go outside, look at it as a place to play soccer, not as the thing that supports us all.
   Nature does feed our souls. I have spent my life getting out as much as possible--without the ability to go outside--hike, ski, hang out, write/paint, do whatever, freely with no time-frame or direction once in a while, I would indeed go crazy.
   Seeing the connections between the land/wildlife/water, FEELING those connections, feeds my spirit.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

9. 9. rainforestrobin 04:42 PM 1/14/09

   We are ARE nature and cannot live without her. I grew up without a TV (my father got rid of it) and lived several years of my adult life in the wild (very remote areas). I went into the wild rainforest of Australia many years ago a very sick woman and came out healed. I can attest firsthand to the absolute necessity of Mother Nature in our daily lives. Daily I worry about our youth and pain they experience when living in disconnection from Nature. The ramifications of disconnection are staggering.
   
   I realize we cannot all go (in our billions) swarming back into Nature, but there are many alternatives between total disconnection on one hand and mass exodus into Nature (with the result being the further destruction of the wild) on the other hand. Simple organic gardening on a small scale or tree planting or programs that kids can volunteer for that restore Nature...all of these and more can bring about a connection to the wild world around us.
   
   This is vitally good work you are doing here. I am truly excited to see this. Very important. Thank you for being this aware; you give the world a gift.
   
   Robin Easton
   www.nakedineden.com
   (Mine is a nature and eco-spiritual site that you may enjoy.)
   

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this