See Inside

Hands in the Air: How Gesturing Helps Us to Think [Preview]

Gestures reveal subconscious knowledge and cement new ideas

In Brief

• Congenitally blind people move their hands when talking, implying that we gesture not only for our listeners but for ourselves.
• Common gestures include pointing, pantomiming actions and capturing abstract ideas by, say, moving a hand forward when talking about the future.
• Children who are on the verge of mastering a task advertise this fact in their gestures.
• Encouraging kids to use gestures can bring out their implicit knowledge and thus change the way they think.

A teacher watches a fourth-grade student try to solve the equation 4 + 3 + 6 =  + 6. The child pencils 13 in the blank. “How did you get that answer?” the teacher asks. “I added the 4 and the 3 and the 6 and got 13,” the child replies. But as the child is talking, he holds one hand under the 6 on the left and the other hand under the 6 on the right, indicating that the child has, at least implicitly, noticed the 6s on both sides of the equation. Thus, the teacher realizes, it is a small mental leap to see that these equal numbers would cancel each other out and that the remaining numbers on the left can be added to get the correct answer, 7. The teacher says, “A better way to solve the problem would be to add the 4 and the 3 and put that number in the blank.” From then on, the child uses this grouping strategy to solve future problems.

In this interchange, which took place in my laboratory while my ­colleagues and I were conducting a study on gesture and learning, neither the teacher nor the student talked about the 6s. But the teacher saw a representation of the two 6s in the student’s gestures, prompting the explicit instruction about grouping. If the student had not gestured in this way, the teacher might have suggested a different method of tackling the problem that might not have been so effective.

This article was originally published with the title Hands in the Air.

View
1. 1. Mudassar 10:30 PM 9/27/10

Susan you highlighted a valid point. I think these gestures reflect the patterns of brain working and the happenings at the proprioceptive levels.

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.

More from Scientific American

• Scientific American Magazine | 14 hours ago | 3

Swiss Cheese and Dust Devils: 7 High-Resolution Shots of Surface Activity on Mars [Slide Show]

• Scientific American Mind | 14 hours ago | 3

Why Do Top Athletes Suddenly Develop “the Yips”—a Tendency to Choke under Pressure?

• Octopus Chronicles | 16 hours ago

Unusual Offshore Octopods: The See-Through "Glass" Octopus [Video]

• News | 17 hours ago | 4

Antarctic Neutrino Observatory Detects Unexplained High-Energy Particles

• Cocktail Party Physics | May 17, 2013

More »

Latest from SA Blog Network

• 33 Years Ago Today...

Rosetta Stones | 2 hours ago
• Friday Weird Science: What's your fart volume?

MIND
The Scicurious Brain | 11 hours ago
• Physics Week in Review: May 18, 2013

Cocktail Party Physics | 12 hours ago
• Deadly Snakes, Ugly Critters, Leonardo DiCaprio and Other Links from the Brink

Extinction Countdown | 15 hours ago
• Unusual Offshore Octopods: The See-Through "Glass" Octopus [Video]

STAFF
Octopus Chronicles | 16 hours ago

Science Jobs of the Week

Hands in the Air: How Gesturing Helps Us to Think: Scientific American Mind

X

Subscribe Today

Save 66% off the cover price and get a free gift!

X

X

Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X