FALLOUT OF FEAR: People far away from Japan's damaged nuclear plant have been donning surgical masks and snatching up potassium iodine pills, but far-flung isotopes are unlikely to pose many health risks, experts note. Image: iStockphoto/Casarsa
More In This Article
Infinitesimal radioactive isotopes can be carried along on the breeze, landing unseen on the ground, clothes and skin. These tiny products of nuclear reactions are capable of causing large-scale bodily damage if they make it inside through inhalation, ingestion or even a cut. And many fear that such isotopes spewed from the damaged Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant are traveling inter-continentally—and in higher quantities than Japanese officials are reporting.
This invisible threat has spurred people as far from Japan as the U.S. and Europe to snatch up and swallow potassium iodine pills in hopes of staving off any accumulation of radioactive iodine 131 particles in their thyroid glands (which can lead to cancer).
Although the most pressing immediate health concern is the powerful direct gamma radiation that threatens workers at the plant, "we need also to focus on the radioactive isotopes that are being dispersed at some distance from the plant," Ira Helfand, a former president of Physicians for Social Responsibility, said at a Wednesday news conference organized by that group, which is opposed to nuclear power.
The Japanese government has maintained that residents of Tokyo, some 220 kilometers south of the compromised Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant, are not facing dangerous levels of radiation. Winds are expected to shift slightly more southerly at the end of the weekend, which could move more radioactive isotopes toward the capital city, but a rainstorm predicted for Sunday could help knock many of these harmful particles out of the air.
Some nuclear experts are concerned that "even if the total radiation dose is not real high downwind from a plant, the concentration of these isotopes can pose a very serious health problem," Helfand said.
The correlations among total body radiation exposure, ingested or inhaled isotopes and cancer are convoluted at best. The major studies in this field have used event-based samples, such as survivors of the atomic bombs dropped on Japan by the U.S. in World War II, to measure and map cancer rates years out.
The clean "linear relationship between your dose of total body radiation and the effect on your health is really lost when you're talking about low-dose radiation at some distance from the source," Helfand said. "You can have a very small total body radiation dose and end up getting thyroid cancer, or ingest some radioactive strontium and end up getting leukemia."
But the likelihood of this event causing large-scale cancer increases in the Tokyo population is slim, says Jeffrey Clanton, director of radiopharmacy services at Vanderbilt University Medical Center.
Iodine 131 is relatively short-lived (with a half-life of about eight days, compared with strontium 90, which decays to half its potency in 29 years). So the spent fuel stores would likely have already lost the majority of their iodine 131 before last Friday's earthquake and tsunami damaged the plant, Clanton explains. And any that is released "will most likely fall out of the atmosphere fairly quickly."
Strontium 90 isotopes, however, are a concern because the body treats them like calcium, integrating them into the bone, which can cause leukemia. But, Clanton says, they are not likely to travel more than a few kilometers—"five miles, probably, max."
Plutonium is of graver concern because of its exceptionally long half-life (about 24,000 years) and its propensity to cause lung cancer if inhaled. (There is plutonium in the fuel rods used at reactor No. 3 at the Fukushima complex.)
Clanton, however, maintains that a person would have to inhale or ingest "a reasonably large amount" of one or more radioactive isotopes to see negative effects. "It would take more than I've seen published from the area."
People in the U.S. purchasing prophylactic potassium iodine pills (which saturate the thyroid with regular iodine in hopes of preventing the uptake of radioactive iodine 131) "are wasting their money," Clanton says.
Winds of concern
No matter how much radioactive material is released, the worrisome isotopes from the Fukushima Daiichi facility are not particularly likely to follow a Chernobyl-scale distribution, Clanton notes. Even if the fuel temperatures fail to drop significantly, it is unlikely to produce the type of catastrophic explosion that launched so much radioactive material into the atmosphere over Chernobyl 25 years ago. The material at Fukushima also lacks the graphite-tipped control rods that were elemental in dispersing the isotopes from the Chernobyl event.