# July 2008 Puzzle Solution

A great-grandfather makes his family work for their land and fortune

Solution:

As you can see pictorially here, even if we move M to M', the intersection of the crossing line with Euclid remains the same. The first question is how to prove it. The second is: Where is the intersection point with Euclid?

Call the distance from Euclid to the pine P and the distance from Euclid to the maple M. In what follows, we will count in hundreds of meters. Thus, E is 2 units to the east of the intersection and W is 4 units to the west of the intersection.

Slope of EP is –P/2. Further, when x = 0, y = P.

So, the equation of EP is:
(1) y = (–P/2)x + P
Similarly, EM has the equation:
(2) y = –(M/2)x + M

Slope of WP is P/4, and when x = 0, y = P. So:
(3) y = (P/4)x + P
Similarly, WM has the equation:
(4) y = (M/4)x + M

L is the intersection of (1) and (4) and occurs when:
(–P/2)x + P = (M/4)x + M
x(M/4+P/2) = P – M = x(M+2P)/4

So, at L, x = 4(P–M)/(M+2P)
The y in that case is (from equation 1):
–2P(P–M)/(M+2P) + P = (2PM–2P2+MP+2P2)/(M+2P) = 3PM/(M+2P)

Checking, from equation 4:
M(P–M)/(M+2P) + M = (–M2+PM+M2+2PM)/(M+2P) = 3PM/(M+2P)

R is the intersection of (2) and (3) and occurs when:
(–M/2)x + M = (P/4)x + P

So, it follows that:
M – P = x(P/4+M/2) = x(P+2M)/4
and
x = 4(M–P)/(2M+P)

Substituting in equation (2), we get a y value:
–2M(M–P)/(2M+P) + M = (–2M2+ 2PM + 2M2+ PM)/(2M+P) = (3PM)/(2M+P)

Substituting into (3):
P(M–P)/(2M+P) + P = (MP–P2+ 2MP+P2)/(2M+P) = 3PM/(2M+P)

Now we want the line between the two points L and R:
L is (4(P–M)/(M+2P), 3PM/(M+2P))
and
R is (4(M–P)/(2M+P), 3PM/(2M+P))

prod = (M+2P)(2M+P)

Delta Y = 3PM(1/(M+2P) – 1/(2M+P))
= 3PM(2M+P–M–2P)/prod = 3PM(M–P)/prod

Delta X = 4((P–M)/(M+2P) – (M–P)/(2M+P))
= 4(P–M)(1/(M+2P) + 1/(2M+P)) = 4(P–M)(2M+P+M+2P)/prod
= 12(P–M)(M+P)

Delta Y/Delta X = PM(M–P)/4(P–M)(M+P)
= –PM/4(P+M)

Now check it on L:
3PM/(M+2P) = (4(P–M)/(M+2P))(–PM/4(P+M)) + b
= (–PM(P–M)/(M+2P)(P+M)) + b

So, b = (3PM(P+M) + (–PM(P–M)))/(M+2P)(P+M)
= (2P^2M+4PM^2)/(M+2P)(P+M)

Therefore, we can set y to 0 (meaning we are trying to find a point on Euclid) and ask for the x value at that point:

0 = (–PM/4(P+M))x + (2P^2M+4PM^2)/(M+2P)(P+M)

So, (PM/4(P+M))x = (2P^2M+4PM^2)/(M+2P)(P+M)

Therefore:

x = 4(P+M)(2P^2M+4PM^2)/PM(M+2P)(P+M)
= 4 (2PPM+4PMM)/PM(M+2P)
= 8PM(M+2P)/PM
= 8

So, just look 8 units (800 meters) east on Euclid.

Can you find a solution that requires less algebra?

The essence of this problem (like last month's) comes from the nice elementary geometry text by Edwin Moise and Floyd Downs entitled Geometry (ISBN 0-201-25335-6, Addison-Wesley, 1991).]

Dennis Shasha is at the Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, New York University. His most recent puzzle book, Puzzles for Programmers and Pros, was published in May 2007 by John Wiley and Sons/Wrox.

View
1. 1. waterbergs 02:58 PM 7/6/08

The solution to this one is simple once one assumes that there is a solution! If this is so and the searcher can't determine which is the right pine and maple,but can still find the treasure, the site of the treasure must be independent of M and P. One can then choose M at infinity, EM and WM are then vertical. WL is then clearly twice ER, and so the treasure must be 600m east of E, i.e. 800m east of Pythagoras on Euclid - 1 minutes work.

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.

## More from Scientific American

• @ScientificAmerican | 12 hours ago

### Can We Harness Disruption to Improve Our World's Future?

• News | 13 hours ago

### Federal Flood Maps Left New York Unprepared for Sandy, and FEMA Knew It

• News | 15 hours ago

### Smart Wig Could Compete with Google Glass

• News | 16 hours ago | 1

### Will to Persevere Can Be Triggered by Electric Stimulation

• Climatewire | 17 hours ago | 6

More »

## Latest from SA Blog Network

• ### Wonderful Things: The Pugnacious, Alien-esque Skeleton Shrimp

The Artful Amoeba | 11 hours ago
• ### Can We Harness Disruption to Improve Our World's Future?

STAFF
@ScientificAmerican | 13 hours ago
• ### British Storm Brings Up History's First Work of Social Media

Plugged In | 13 hours ago
• ### Rolling on Wheels That Aren t Round

Observations | 14 hours ago
• ### The future of nuclear energy: Let a thousand flowers bloom

The Curious Wavefunction | 14 hours ago

## Science Jobs of the Week

July 2008 Puzzle Solution

X

Give a 1 year subscription as low as \$14.99

X

X

###### Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X