# Penelope Maddy: A Philosopher You Can Count On

A 1968 Westinghouse finalist is now a philosopher of science—and professor of logic

• Overview

#### More Finalist Profiles

Her finalist year: 1968

Her finalist project: Figuring out the algebraic properties of collections of objects

What led to the project: Penelope Maddy always liked math, but she got particularly excited about the subject in her ninth grade algebra class at what is now Dana Middle School in San Diego. "It amazed me that you could take those little bits of information in a word problem, translate them into an equation or two, and find out the answer," she says. "I guess it was my first real inkling of the power of mathematics."

Her teacher showed her a book on abstract algebra—the study of "number systems" in which the "numbers" are not what most people would think of as numbers at all. Maddy considered what happens if the "numbers" are sets (a collection of things, like all the solar system’s planets, or all the members of Congress). "I'm sure there was nothing of continuing interest in it," she says. But when she entered it in the 1968 Westinghouse Science Talent Search she was named a finalist, and then placed seventh overall. This was particularly exciting, because on her trip to Washington, D.C., she says, "I saw snow for the first time in my life!"

The effect on her career: Maddy knew she wanted to continue to study set theory. So she enrolled at the University of California, Berkeley, as a math major.

Even in high school, however, she had started to ponder the limits of what sets can be used to prove. In particular, she was interested in what we can know and cannot know about infinite numbers. In math, there isn't just one "infinity," Maddy notes. There are many infinite numbers of different sizes. To begin with, there's the size of the set of natural numbers (1, 2, 3, 4…). However, the set of real numbers (those corresponding to all the points on a line, including between those numbers), which is also infinite, is bigger than the set of natural numbers. All the different infinities can be lined up -- the smallest, then the next biggest, and so forth -- and many of the familiar operations, like multiplication or raising numbers to an exponent, can be defined on these infinite numbers.

These different infinite numbers also present some perplexing problems: For instance, what happens if you take the number 2 and raise it to the smallest infinite number? "The answer will have to be infinite, but which infinite number is it?" she asks. The smallest, the next smallest…? Something called "The continuum hypothesis" (CH), proposed by Georg Cantor in the 1870s, says that the answer is the second infinite number, but whether the CH is true or false cannot be proved via the normal methods, Maddy says. You can't show whether it's true "without adding some new fundamental axiom"—that is, a basic assumption that can't be founded on anything more basic. "And nobody's yet found a satisfactory way of doing that."

To Maddy, this didn't seem like just a straightforward math question. She started to wonder: How do you justify a fundamental mathematical assumption? "You can't prove it, because it's the place where all proofs begin. So what do you do?"

When she started musing on questions like this, "it was the beginning of the end for me," she says. "I was headed into philosophy." She went to Princeton University to earn a PhD in the topic, receiving her degree in 1979. (Her thesis looked at the continuum hypothesis.) She began teaching at the University of Notre Dame and then at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

What she's doing now: Since 1987, Maddy has been a professor of logic and philosophy of science and of mathematics at U.C. Irvine, where she continues to ponder—and teach—the CH and other questions. She combines history and set theory in her work, and is a "highly respected and influential philosopher," says Donald A. "Tony" Martin, a set theorist and philosopher of mathematics at U.C.L.A.

View
1. 1. Psychology 76 01:09 PM 1/13/09

Interesting!

2. 2. arfnotz 02:12 PM 1/13/09

Very cool to find out where all those Westinghouse/Intel winners end up. I've heard a fair percentage do not pursue math/science/engineering disciplines, those are the interesting ones.

Good article!

3. 3. halidom 10:35 PM 1/13/09

The idea of infinity having various sizes sound ridicules. If normal numbers
1 2 3 ad infinitum are used, it has no end. If you use each number with a decimal place going ad infinitum it sound like it would be bigger, but both have no end, infinity. As for philosophy that's just how we live and perceive our surroundings. Everyone is a philosopher. What they teach is how other people viewed life.

4. 4. Mr.Bip 11:54 PM 1/13/09

I recall trying some experiments in geometry on a computer. When I made certain constructions I was surprised that a completely new theorem jumped out. I had the strong feeling that I discovered it rather than inventing it. Nothing new here - lots of mathematicians get that feeling. I think that somehow the realist / naturalist disagreement will never be settled satisfactorily because each has intractable problems.

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.

## More from Scientific American

• Scientific American Magazine | 47 minutes ago

### Summer Blockbuster: A Black Hole Swallows a Cloud

• News | 14 hours ago | 5

### Infant Tooth Reveals Neandertal Breastfeeding Habits

• Ask the Experts | 14 hours ago

### Why Twisters Hammer Tornado Alley

• TechMediaNetwork | 15 hours ago | 3

### Rare View of Ancient Galaxy Crash Revealed

• Guest Blog | 16 hours ago

More »

## Latest from SA Blog Network

• ### A Brief History of Mental Illness In Art

MIND
Brainwaves | 25 minutes ago
• ### Deciphering the Strange Mathematics of Cicadas [Video]

Observations | 1 hour ago
• ### The Cataclysm: "From Unbaked Fragments to Vitreous Charcoal"

Rosetta Stones | 4 hours ago
• ### Illusion of the week: It Kind Of Looks Like a Building

MIND
Illusion Chasers | 8 hours ago
• ### #SciAmBlogs Wednesday - niche construction, cicadas, ageing, Moon, pirates' dodo, sick caecilians, hurricane forecasts, and more.

STAFF
The Network Central | 9 hours ago

## Science Jobs of the Week

Penelope Maddy: A Philosopher You Can Count On

X

### Subscribe Today

Save 66% off the cover price and get a free gift!

X

X

###### Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X