# Straight Hair Is Knottier Than Curly Hair

Straight hair may seem easy to brush but it actually tangles more often than curly locks

TRICKY TANGLE: A mathematical model shows that straight hair tangles more often than curly hair. Image: ©ERIC FOLTZ/ISTOCKPHOTO.COM

• ### Frankenstein's Cat

One of Nature’s Summer Book Picks One of Publishers Weekly’s Top Ten Spring 2013 Science Books For centuries, we’ve toyed with our creature companions,...

On a cool Saturday afternoon at the überhot Garren hair salon in New York City a few masters of fashion were debating something many would call obvious: Which is more likely to tangle—curly hair or straight hair?

The seemingly straight answer, if you will: "When we put a [model] in a wind machine, we can still put a comb through her hair—if it's straight. Curly? Forget it," says Robert Vasquez, a hairstylist who specializes in what his industry terms "difficult" hair.

But what appears, at first thought, to be obvious can become surprisingly fuzzy. "I'm not convinced that curly hair tangles more," says Steven Fernandes, who combs up to 20 manes daily at Garren. "Straight hair is lighter and strands move individually, but curly hair moves as one movement and so is less tangled."

Jean-Baptiste Masson, a young brain imaging researcher at the École Polytechnique in France, recently pulled apart this question as a class exercise in mathematical modeling.

With hundreds of thousands of micro-thin strands colliding in every direction, hair is an unusually complicated system—a set of independent objects working as an integrated whole. And, unlike other  systems such as fluids and solids, hair mechanics remains unsolved, with no widely accepted model to explain it. "I needed a problem for my students, and I thought hair is something that could be simplified," Masson says.

He enlisted two hairdressers to count the number of tangles on 212 heads over three weeks. The stylists were instructed to look for true tangles, namely a clump that resisted the draw of a comb but was not a cluster of hair—like a ringlet, or curl.

Based on these criteria, curly hair averages about three tangles per head whereas straight averages more than five tangles. The surprising results, and a mathematical model of tangling, were recently published in the American Journal of Physics.

In Masson's model, it turns out that even though curly strands meet more often than straight strands, the angle at which two straight hairs meet is the angle most likely to lead to tangling.

But there's no particular explanation for why different angles lead to different tangling patterns, argues Alain Goriely, professor of mathematics at the University of Arizona in Tucson, who studies the math of biological systems.

Masson explains that the optimal tangle angle is one that is large enough to hook the microscopic, fishlike "scales" that coat hair cuticles. If this angle is too narrow—meaning the two hairs are nearly parallel—they won't lock.

It turns out that Masson's model predicts the real-world hairdresser data with surprising accuracy.

Masson's "math lesson" has inspired computer scientists like Florence Bertails, an expert in hair behavior at The French National Institute for Research in Computer Science and Control, to consider using models like the one Masson devised to inform her more complicated computer algorithms.

Back at Garren, Fernandes has the last point, "You know what the real issue is? The real issue is fine versus coarse. Curly or straight, fine hair is what tangles. The cuticle is open and puffy, like Velcro—it'll stick to anything."

The others nod their heads dramatically. "Oh yes, that's it," says Vasquez, "dry, fine, chemically treated hair tangles the most."

Rights & Permissions

### Add a Comment

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.

## More from Scientific American

• Octopus Chronicles | 12 hours ago

### Octopus In Space: Why the Latest U.S. Spy Rocket Is More Appropriate Than the NRO Knows

• TechMediaNetwork | 12 hours ago | 5

### Radiation on Mars 'Manageable' for Manned Mission, Curiosity Rover Reveals

• News | 12 hours ago | 2

### Powder Rive Basin Coal on the Move

• TechMediaNetwork | 12 hours ago | 1

### Formula 1 Racing Loud Enough to Damage Hearing

• News | 14 hours ago | 1

### Strategies for Aging Vary Widely across 46 Species with Some Scarcely Deteriorating

See what we're tweeting about

More »

## Latest from SA Blog Network

• ### Octopus In Space: Why the Latest U.S. Spy Rocket Is More Appropriate Than the NRO Knows

STAFF
Octopus Chronicles | 11 hours ago
• ### Oh the Horror! Best of the Blogs for November...

Video of the Week | 14 hours ago
• ### Best of the Blogs for November: Oh the Horror!!

PsiVid | 14 hours ago
• ### 4 Billion Years of Martian History in 2 Minutes

Life, Unbounded | 16 hours ago
• ### My Story Collider Story - Working Twice as Hard

The Urban Scientist | 16 hours ago

## Science Jobs of the Week

Straight Hair Is Knottier Than Curly Hair

X

### Give a Gift & Get a Gift - Free!

Give a 1 year subscription as low as \$14.99

X

X

###### Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

Yes, please link my existing account with for quick, secure access.

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X

### Institutional Access

It has been identified that the institution you are trying to access this article from has institutional site license access to Scientific American on nature.com. To access this article in its entirety through site license access, click below.

X

X