From Nature magazine

Nestling among the dunes in the dry equatorial region of Saturn's moon Titan is what appears to be a hydrocarbon lake. The observation, by the Cassini spacecraft, suggests that oases of liquid methane — which might be a crucible for life — lie beneath the moon's surface. The work is published today in Nature.

Besides Earth, Titan is the only solid object in the Solar System to circulate liquids in a cycle of rain and evaporation, although on Titan the process is driven by methane rather than water.

This cycle is expected to form liquid bodies near the moon's poles, but not at its dune-covered equator, where Cassini measurements show that humidity levels are low and little rain falls to the surface. "The equatorial belt is like a desert on Earth, where evaporation trumps precipitation," says astrobiologist Jonathan Lunine of Cornell University in Ithaca, New York.

Any surface liquid there should evaporate and be transported to the cooler poles, where it should condense as rain. "Lakes at the poles are easy to explain, but lakes in the tropics are not," says Caitlin Griffith, a planetary scientist at the University of Arizona in Tucson. Indeed, Cassini has spotted hundreds of lakes and three seas in Titan's polar regions.

Now Griffith and her colleagues think they have found a tropical lake — some 60 kilometres long and 40 kilometres wide, and at least 1 metre deep — in Cassini observations made between 2004 and 2008. It appears as a black splotch at seven near-infrared wavelengths that can travel relatively unimpeded through the moon's thick atmosphere, which blocks visible light.

Caverns measureless to man
The team also found four smaller, brighter splotches, which Griffith says may be "shallower ponds similar to marshes on Earth, with knee-to-ankle-level depths". Because tropical lakes on Titan should evaporate over a period of just a few thousand years, the researchers argue that these ponds and lakes are being replenished by subsurface oases of liquid methane.

That would expand the number of places on the moon where life could potentially originate. Methane, which is made up of one carbon and four hydrogen atoms, is the source of more complicated organic molecules found on Titan. "There may be organic chemical processes that occur in liquid hydrocarbons that could lead to compounds analogous to proteins and information-carrying molecules," says Lunine, who was not involved in the work. "There might be a kind of life that works in liquid hydrocarbons."

Lunine and Griffith are members of a proposed NASA mission to look for such complex chemistry, called the Titan Mare Explorer (TiME). The TiME probe would spend three months bobbing around Ligeia Mare, a sea near Titan's north polar region, measuring its chemistry with a mass spectrometer.

But should that mission, the fate of which will soon be decided by NASA, land on a tropical lake instead? No, says Lunine. He points out that a number of lines of evidence — including telltale radar signatures — show that the polar regions are filled with liquid hydrocarbon lakes and seas. So far there is less evidence for the tropical features. "Something else that just happens to be dark at those wavelengths", such as a solid organic compound, might mimic a lake, he says.

Only 17% of the equatorial region's surface area has been analysed at the high resolutions required to spot these small features, but Lunine says that lower-resolution observations suggest tropical lakes are relatively few and far between. Still, the idea of oases on Titan appeals to him. "There's a place on Titan named Xanadu, and if you go back to the Coleridge poem on Xanadu, he talks about 'caverns measureless to man',” Lunine says. He adds that he would love to find such caverns filled with methane on Titan.

This article is reproduced with permission from the magazine Nature. The article was first published on June 14, 2012.

10 Comments

1. 1. jtdwyer 02:59 PM 6/14/12

   If you pour organic molecules into liquid methane, don't they fall to the bottom, rather than float and interact as in water? Can liquid methane suspend any molecules of gas to support any form of respiration?

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

2. 2. David Russell in reply to jtdwyer 07:04 PM 6/15/12

   Jim, that is the 64K question. I keep thinking we are going to find life on Titan, only very very slow metabolic life but life none the less.
   
   Have you ever seen stop action photography of star fish. That is about the metabolic rate I would expect but it is life none the less. Can you imagine a hunt to the death that takes about 2 to 3 months from start to finish with about 3 earth years for eating and digesting the nourishment.
   
   The fact that tri state is allowed opens a lot of doors that we cannot explain from our hot little world here but there is chemistry and there is methane production and both point to something happening there.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

3. 3. jtdwyer in reply to David Russell 01:28 PM 6/16/12

   Thanks - well put. You may well be correct. It does appear that there is organic chemistry occurring out there, but there is so much methane that I suspect it could not be the product of marginal biological processes.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

4. 4. Philip Kirk 10:08 AM 6/18/12

   I think the TiME probe should be a NASA priority. Of all the bodies in our solar system, Titan is perhaps the most promising for some form of life. With current technology, would it be possible to set humans on the surface?

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

5. 5. DougAlder 01:36 PM 6/20/12

   Phillip - the real problem here is contamination - how do we absolutely guarantee that what we put down on alien soil is not carrying some life from Earth. Recent experiments on the ISS have shown that cyanobacteria exposed to space for 18 months - alternately boiled, frozen and thoroughly irradiated, suffered no harm.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

6. 6. Cosmoknot 07:33 PM 6/20/12

   "Besides Earth, Titan is the only solid object in the Solar System to circulate liquids in a cycle of rain and evaporation,"
   
   I thought I was informed that Venus has sulfuric acid rainstorms.
   
   Here now appears to be conflicting information.
   
   Oh well. No big deal. I was misinformed.
   On with life, I suppose.
   
   It still kind of bugs me though.......

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

7. 7. HubertB 08:12 PM 6/20/12

   Methane being a non-polar compound would have difficulty reacting with other compounds. For an exotic life form, I would look to the ammonia of Jupiter or the sulphur dioxide of Venus.
   I realize methane undergoes a chemical reaction in the deep ocean on earth. However, there it consists of a molecule surrounded by many polar compounds and ions.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

8. 8. Chris Miller in reply to Cosmoknot 09:19 AM 6/21/12

   Venus has sulfuric acid clouds. I don't know if they can 'rain' high in the atmosphere, but I doubt any could reach the surface, where temperatures are many hundreds of degrees.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

9. 9. Quinn the Eskimo 10:10 PM 6/24/12

   All of us are deluding ourselves! Starting with our own myopic view of what is life. Indeed.
   
   These little methane beings have visited earth! Who do you think built stonehedge? A bunch of druids?

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

10. 10. Grumpyoleman 03:23 PM 7/28/12

    I'd put my money and spaceship on Europa in the search for life. If there is a water ocean under the ice, it is surely more amenable to life than a cold methane environment. It's a much shorter trip than Titan as well.

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this