Sales of television show DVDs have exploded over the past few years. But why do viewers shell out so much cash for what are essentially reruns? A study in the August issue of the Journal of Consumer Research suggests that “reconsumption,” as the researchers call it, is more complex than one might think. People use familiar entertainment to measure how their lives have changed in positive ways.

Cristel Antonia Russell, a marketing professor at American University, and Sidney J. Levy, a marketing professor at the University of Arizona, conducted interviews of 23 subjects, all of whom had recently “reconsumed” a book, movie or vacation spot. The researchers used open-ended questions to elicit long and descriptive first-person answers, then analyzed the transcripts for recurring themes and key phrases. The responses suggested that sometimes choosing to do something again was about reaching for a sure thing—the brain knows the exact kind of reward that it will receive in the end, whether it is laughter, excitement or relaxation. They also learned that people gained insight into themselves and their own growth by going back for a do-over, subconsciously using the rerun or old book as a measuring stick for how their own lives had changed. One woman, for example, rewatched the romantic Kevin Costner movie Message in a Bottle more than once: “It was helping her work through having an engagement that hadn't worked out,” Russell says. Every time she watched that movie, it reminded her of her own failed relationship—and her reactions helped her see she was getting over it.

“I was very surprised,” Russell says. “I thought that people reconsumed these things for nostalgia, to go back to the past. But they were actually very forward-looking and prospective.” What about the boredom factor, you might ask? There was none to speak of. After all, Russell says, paraphrasing Greek philosopher Heraclitus: You never cross the same river twice—it's not the same river, and it's not the same you.

This article was originally published with the title Why You Like to Watch the Same Thing Over, and Over, and Over Again.

7 Comments

1. 1. Bops 11:53 AM 12/7/12

   Based on 23 people.... not valid.
   
   People watch the same old programs because it makes them feel good.
   And because there nothing new worth watching even for the first time.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

2. 2. nanorat 03:09 PM 12/7/12

   We listen to the same songs over & over. That is why we download music. I don't see the difference.
   

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

3. 3. sjfone 06:25 AM 12/8/12

   Quite right, I have a cultural connection each time I watch
   "My Name is Earl".

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

4. 4. voice 08:25 AM 12/8/12

   I agree! And I love the Heraclitus quote. I've been watching Gone with the Wind since I was 7 (for over 50 yrs), and every time my perspective has changed. And the comedy today is hardcore, compared to the old goofy comedy(e.g. Drunk Uncle vs Rosanne Rosannadanna).

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

5. 5. sfpkent 01:58 AM 12/13/12

   Learnt a new thing today. At least I understand why human keep watching the same things again, again and again.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

6. 6. sunnystrobe 06:45 AM 12/13/12

   Play it again, Sam...
   Encore!
   We are animals of habit, after all.
   Romeo & Juliet will never run out of repeat requests; it's the evolutionary all-time hit of the eternal dating & mating theme! the other top topic is of course the adventures of alpha males in the quest of the survival of the fittest. I can bet Darwin 's smiling all the way..

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

7. 7. Glorfindel 03:49 PM 12/14/12

   Reasons for re-watching:
   1. Nostalgia (Dambusters every May 16/17), Tinker Tailor (BBC), for that 60's/70's London/Civil Service atmosphere (I could have been in some of those buildings)
   2. Some movies are unsurpassable (2001: A Space Odyssey)
   3. Knowing you are going to enjoy it
   4. There are things you didn't appreciate even after several viewings.
   So, I am really hoping that BluRays and DVDs don't die out before I do, in favor of "the cloud", when "They" get to control what I can watch.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this