Why Grassroots Initiatives Can't Fix Climate Change

A grassroots approach alone won't make the earth stop warming

Matt Collins

Have you heard enough already about global warming? It’s so ... last year’s news! Plenty of people are “doing something” about it. Becoming carbon-neutral has gone as mainstream as Girl Scout cookies; help is on the way. Can we move on, please?

Unfortunately not. For all the consciousness-raising value of grassroots initiatives,  the world is still far from squarely facing up to the issues. Both Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama promise on their Web sites to reduce carbon emissions to just 20 percent of 1990 levels by 2050—a laudable goal. But because what matters is the load of greenhouse gases in the entire atmosphere, reaching those numbers would be hard, to say the least, for the U.S. to do alone. John McCain’s Web site simply offers “commonsense approaches to limit carbon emissions by harnessing market forces that will ... see to it that ... all nations do their rightful share.”

If the candidates’ statements—perhaps out of political necessity—are short on specifics, the reason is partly that much of the electorate still finds it hard to grasp the size and urgency of the problem. Like the naive passengers on board an ocean liner, who lean carelessly over the rail as their ship drifts into an iceberg, most of us are oblivious to the magnitude of the impending disaster. The separation closes too slowly for us to appreciate the force of the coming crunch.

What is even more misleading, most climate changes so far seem gentle, even pleasant—an earlier spring, a later fall. Only occasionally does an ungentle reminder break through: this past February 160 square miles of Antarctica’s Wilkins ice shelf disintegrated. James Hansen of the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies and his colleagues argue in a recent paper submitted to Science that the present carbon dioxide (CO2) level in the atmosphere, 385 parts per million (ppm), has already crossed into dangerous territory. According to their study of past climatic sensitivity to changes in atmospheric CO2, there is substantial risk that within just a few centuries the earth could lose its great Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets, causing catastrophic rises in sea level, unless CO2 levels are quickly brought back to 350 ppm.

All six of the scenarios considered by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assume that by the end of this century atmospheric greenhouse gases will reach the warming equivalent of 600 ppm of CO2 (600 ppm CO2-eq). At that level the IPCC pegs the chances at about two thirds that by 2100 the earth will have warmed between two and three degrees Celsius (between 3.6 and 5.4 degrees Fahrenheit) since preindustrial times. If concentrations rise to 1,250 ppm CO2-eq or above, as they do in two of the IPCC scenarios, the chances become about one in six that the warming will exceed five degrees C (nine degrees F). According to the Stern Review, a major report on the economics of climate change, a five-degree increase would be “far outside the experience of human civilisation.” It would also risk “irreversible ... physical changes, such as the collapse of ocean currents,” as well as “mass migrations and social instability.” It gets worse. The IPCC puts the chances at 5 percent that even if CO2-eq levels stabilize at 550 ppm, global temperatures will eventually rise by eight degrees C (14.4 degrees F).

Both the Stern Review and John Broome, in his article “The Ethics of Climate Change,” are explicit about the ethical dimensions of society’s response to global warming. At bottom, the issue is much like the one older voters must face when their local government proposes a hike in school taxes. How much do we really care about the well-being of future generations? How much of the good life in the present are we willing to forgo to provide for our children and grandchildren?

Rights & Permissions
or subscribe to access other articles from the June 2008 publication.
Digital Issue $7.99
Digital Issue + All Access Subscription $99.99 Subscribe
Share this Article:


You must sign in or register as a member to submit a comment.

Starting Thanksgiving

Enter code: HOLIDAY 2015
at checkout

Get 20% off now! >


Email this Article