Aug 20, 2008 02:25 PM in Basic Science | 22 comments
Bigfoot expert on the big hoax: "It's really comical"
By Adam Hadhazy
If you haven’t heard already, the Bigfoot claim from last week is debunked – the supposed Sasquatch in the freezer box is just a costume, according to admissions from its alleged finders, Rick Dyer and Matthew Whitton.
In an additional bit of fraudulent behavior, a posting on Searching for Bigfoot, Inc.’s Web site claims that these men from Georgia have now run off with an undisclosed sum of money advanced to them by the company.
Now that this Bigfoot ballyhoo is wrapping up, ScientificAmerican.com called up Jeffrey Meldrum again to get his reaction about how the whole thing went down. Meldrum is a professor of anatomy and anthropology at Idaho State University in Pocatello, and has studied the Bigfoot phenomenon in depth.
Here’s an edited transcript of what Meldrum had to say:
What are your thoughts on how this "tall tale" of finding Bigfoot ended?
Well, it comes as no surprise. It unraveled pretty much as I anticipated it would. The only alternate scenario was that the body would disappear, and conspiracy theories would have abounded about how some “men in black” or government agents had swiped [the Bigfoot cadaver]. But what actually happened was the most likely scenario, and [the ruse] could only have been sustained for so long. It’s really comical.
Did the handlers of this Bigfoot claim do anything right?
The only seemingly legitimate action that they made was to recruit a bona-fide microbiologist, Curtis Nelson [of the University of Minnesota]. He said he received three samples [for genetic testing], and that they were of muscle, blood and hair. One of these samples came out as 100 percent human. A second sample couldn’t be sequenced for technical reasons. Then there was a mixture which turned out to be 97 percent possum with some human [gene sequences] mixed in. [Nelson] thought there was contamination possibly from whoever handled or procured the sample, but he admits there’s no way to really know. This goes back to the lack of a chain of custody or [any knowledge of] how the samples were collected in the first place. I’m guessing that the muscle was possum, and that maybe the hair or blood was [from a] human.
What do you think the impact of this sham will be on the continued investigation of Bigfoot’s existence?
The only positive thing that has come from it is that it has gotten people very interested again in Bigfoot. But this singular event does not necessarily represent the entire issue at hand – the question of the existence of Bigfoot does not pivot on whether the costume or corpse in the freezer turned out to be genuine. So that turns the conversation to legitimate efforts of mine and others to try and find out if there’s anything actually to the Bigfoot [myths].
Read More About: dyer, bigfoot hoax, bogus sasquatch, whitton, rubber costume, meldrum, biscardi.
You Might Also Like
Discuss This Article
Subscription Center
World Changing Ideas
-
Video ContestInnovation is the key to a better future. Enter your own World Changing Ideas videos in our contest.
Most Popular Blog Posts
9,000-year-old brew hitting the shelves this summer
Manipulative meow: Cats learn to vocalize a particular sound to train their human companions
Wylie Coywolf: The coyote-wolf hybrid has made its way to the Northeast
A lizard that swims through sand
Scientists urge EPA to assess potential phthalates risks
Editor's Pick
-
Time to Ban Production of Nuclear Weapons MaterialA new global treaty that cuts off production of plutonium and highly enriched uranium for nuclear weapons could jump-start nuclear disarmament and help prevent proliferation
Basic Science Newsletter
Get weekly coverage delivered to your inboxVideo
Podcasts
-
60-Second Science
RSS ·
iTunes
Botoxed Face Impairs Bad Feelings
click to enable
-
60-Second Science
RSS ·
iTunes
Distracted Customers' Wait Times Fly
click to enable
Slideshows
Street Smarts: The BioBus Brings a Rolling Science Lab to Resource-Strapped Schools
Third-hand smoke contains carcinogens too, study says
Sperm cells' swimming secrets revealed



