Mar 31, 2008 06:08 AM in Basic Science | Post a comment
Food versus fuel, or can we have both?
By David Biello
Rufino Uribe (cc-by-sa-2.0)
"In June more than 50 percent of fuels will be coming from agriculture in my country," former minister of agriculture Roberto Rodrigues said at the State of the Planet conference. That is a good thing, since ethanol from sugar cane delivers roughly nine times more energy as fuel than it takes to produce it (as compared with corn, which delivers less or only slightly more, depending on whose analysis you trust).
But, according to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), a growing world population will require 42 percent more production of grain and meat in the next two decades. And planting more sugarcane displaces other crops or pasture, which can then lead to more clearing of the Amazon rainforest, as a recent study in Science showed.
Rodrigues argues that the food-versus-fuel debate is misleading. "Agriculture will be not only be providing food but everything to live," he said. "Some say production of biofuels will reduce production of food. This is not true. This is a lie."
For instance, sugar cane fields must be rotated to other crops, such as soy, every five years, meaning that 20 percent of the land used to grow the sweet grass will be in actual food production in any given year. And sugarcane is not a staple food crop, which means using it to produce fuel won't directly affect food prices.
If sugarcane does displace other food crops because of demand for fuel, as some studies have shown, then the rich will be filling their gas tanks as the poor starve. And Rodrigues made no promises about the ongoing deforestation in the Amazon in response to a question from the audience.
But there is still one compelling argument in favor of ethanol: you can drink it. As Rodrigues notes, he has been doing so in the form of caipirinhas for years and his motor at the age of 65 is still running fine.
You Might Also Like
Discuss This Article
Subscription Center
Most Popular Blog Posts
9,000-year-old brew hitting the shelves this summer
AIDS vaccine surprises scientists, proves partially successful
World's leading protector of the oceans? President Bush
Wanted: Home for 17,000 tons of mercury
Is birth control the answer to environmental ills?
Editor's Pick
-
Powering a Green Planet: Sustainable Energy, Made InteractiveThe Web-only article below is a special rich-media presentation of the feature, "A Path to Sustainable Energy by 2030", which appears in the November 2009 issue of Scientific American. It was created by FlypMedia.com. Use the arrow in the lower corner to navigate
Basic Science Newsletter
Get weekly coverage delivered to your inboxVideo
Podcasts
-
60-Second Earth
RSS ·
iTunes
Capturing Carbon Dioxide
click to enable
-
60-Second Science
RSS ·
iTunes
Babies Already Have An Accent
click to enable
Slideshows
Frozen Antarctic lakes yield new viruses
15 Answers to Creationist Nonsense
NASA-funded monkey-radiation experiment raises hackles
What will it take to force political action on climate change?
Google Droid is here: Can it go toe-to-toe with Apple's iPhone?
First Look at Carbon Capture and Storage in a West Virginia Coal-Fired Power Plant [Slide Show]
Don't Let the Bedbugs Bite: Pest Management Proves More Effective than Pesticides



