• More Blogs
• Observations »
• Bering in Mind »
• Cross-check »
• Extinction Countdown »
• Solar at Home »
• Expeditions »
• Guest Blog »
• Anecdotes from the Archive »

A new study has found that hospitals could cut surgery complications by about 30 percent and resulting deaths by 40 percent if doctors and nurses follow a checklist of safety rules before, during and after performing surgery.

The checklist, issued by the World Health Organization last year in response to soaring reports of hospital errors, lists 19 steps that surgical teams should follow, starting with making sure that the right patient is on the operating table, the site of incision has been located, and that the proper procedure is about to be performed. "In this era of highly intense and sophisticated technology, sometimes a very simple technology, which only takes a few minutes, can have a very positive impact," says Richard Reznick, head of surgery at the University of Toronto in Canada and co-author of the study published today in the New England Journal of Medicine.

He and fellow researchers collected data on surgery complications and deaths of 7,688 surgical patients at eight hospitals in Seattle, Toronto, London, Auckland, Ifakara, (Tanzania), Manila (Philippines), New Delhi (India), and Amman (Jordan).  These hospitals did not initially require use of the WHO safety checklist but adopted it during the course of the study. The goal of the research was to find out how implementing the checklist impacted the number of surgery complications and deaths. Of the 3,733 patients who had surgeries before the checklists went into use, 411 (11 percent) suffered complications (such as pneumonia and skin infections) and 56 (1.5 percent) of them died; of the 3,955 patients who were operated on after the hospitals adopted the WHO guide, 277 (7 percent) suffered complications and 32 (0.8 percent) died.

This study "is an attempt to make this an international standard," says Reznick, noting that the majority of hospitals around the world do not use the guidelines. But he cautions that this is just one way to prevent unnecessary complications and deaths. He says hospitals should also, among other things, mandate infection control programs to prevent post-surgery infections.

Some 234 million major surgeries are performed around the world annually, roughly one operation for every 25 people, according to WHO. The international aid agency estimates that approximately half of all surgical complications are preventable.

"Attention to patient safety will pay dividends, in terms of lessening complications and saving lives," Reznick says. "[The idea is to] try to enact things globally."

Image credit ©iStockphoto.com/Jacob Wackerhausen

3 Comments

1. 1. Jillipepper 08:05 PM 1/14/09

   Having worked in the medical field for 25 years, I can say that when new plans like this come up they are well followed but with time and an overworked medical system eventually it won't be followed. Bit by bit steps will be skipped UNLESS there is a person who watches the whole procedure and checks off each step as they go but has no other responsibilities during the surgery. Hopefully they will take things like this into consideration when implementing such programs.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

2. 2. tknapp5 12:06 AM 1/15/09

   I've read the entire article. There was no control group (as the authors acknowledge), so the results are really not properly interpretible, and causality cannot be claimed.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

3. 3. ChrisJones 12:20 PM 1/15/09

   Does this mean that they, for some dumb ass reason... pride, arrogance, whatever... DO NOT already follow checklists? How moron-simple is this answer? ANY process that requires that numerous specific things happen in a certain order, from flying airplanes to building birdhouses to many surgical procedures, benefit from the use of checklists.
   
   This one gets four and a half "Duhs."
   

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this