• More Blogs
• Observations »
• Bering in Mind »
• Cross-check »
• Extinction Countdown »
• Solar at Home »
• Expeditions »
• Guest Blog »
• Anecdotes from the Archive »

Crash, crash. Doom, doom. Panic on the Street. Wall Street yesterday suffered its worst decline since the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks – and the free fall suggests it may be time to consider burying the family stash of Krugerrands under the rose garden or tool shed.

The list of Chicken Little events was long:  investment house Lehman’s bankruptcy, the capital crunch for mega-insurer AIG, the sale of Merrill Lynch to Bank of America. But Stormy Monday (a weather system that appears to be carrying over to be lingering) probably came as no surprise to a cadre of mathematicians who specialize in surveying the dynamics of markets.

One of those long-time market watchers is fractal pioneer Benoit Mandelbrot. In 1999, Scientific American published an article by Mandelbrot that showed how fractal geometry can model market volatility, while revealing the intrinsic deficiencies of a cornerstone of finance called modern portfolio theory (for which there has been awarded more than one Nobel Prize in Economics).

Mandelbrot, 83, contends that portfolio theory, which tries to maximize return for a given level of risk, treats extreme events (like, say, yesterday's market shockers) with “benign neglect: it regards large market shifts as too unlikely to matter or as impossible to take into account.” The faulty assumption of modern portfolio theorists, in Mandelbrot’s view, is that price changes do not drift far from the mean when observing daily ups and downs—so extreme events are exceedingly rare. “Typhoons, in effect, are defined out of existence,” he wrote.

In place of modern portfolio theory’s reliance on the canonical Bell Curve, Mandelbrot drags in (surprise!) the fractal. A fractal is a geometric shape that can be divvied up into parts, each of which is a Mini-Me facsimile of the whole. If you look closely enough, you can see fractals everywhere. Besides monotonous screen savers, fractal patterns describe the distribution of galaxies and the shape of coastlines. Mandelbrot devised so-called multi-fractal generators that can use historical market data to simulate alternative scenarios of where stocks or other securities might be headed.

The experience of editing Mandelbrot a decade ago was both fun and exasperating. Trying to translate the complexities of multifractals into a finished text demanded a lot of neural gear grinding to say the least.
Dealing with this renowned creator of the Mandelbrot set was another challenge.

The conversation always seemed to drift back to his other favorite subject: how the rest of the world  did not appreciate the  value of his work. At one point, I asked  whether he believed he should receive a Nobel (highly unlikely for a mathematician).  One does not discuss such things, he said, as if it might jinx his chances.

We received a stack of letters and e-mails after the article was published, including a bundle from adherents of  the so-called Elliott Wave Theory alleging that Mandelbrot had lifted his ideas (on the multifractal nature of markets) from the work of Ralph Nelson Elliott in the 1930s. An insulted Mandelbrot dismissed the charges with withering disdain: “The idea is ancient, but his use and mine stand in absolute contrast,” he responded in the mag's letters column.

Perhaps the most telling criticism of Mandelbrot’s work comes from the markets themselves. In the decade or so since his article was published, the use of multifractal market analysis is still largely an academic endeavor. But Mandelbrot should not be judged too harshly. Multifractals may not be in routine use on the trading floors. But Mandelbrot’s work on market extremes has served to broadcast to the Street a notion that has been known forever on the street: Yes, Virginia, sh*t really does happen.

Photo of Benoit Mandelbrot, 2007, by Rama

15 Comments

1. 1. scientificamericanaism 11:09 AM 9/23/08

   Mandelbrot's multi-fractal generator brings up many interesting questions and ideas. As Mandelbrot attempted to simulate market patterns, Mandelbrot resorted to adding a speed value to his multi-fractals in order to make the charts more realistic. The speed value allowed certain parts of the multi-fractal to copy smaller versions of itself within itself at different rates/ speeds/ frequency than other parts of the non-speed affected areas of the larger fractal. Even with the speed variable, multi-fractals are still unable to reproduce realistic market charts. But, perhaps different parts of the fractal contain different speed values...
   

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

2. 2. benvoxley 12:58 PM 9/30/08

   We knew this was coming. Please watch this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yul0nnilILw

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

3. 3. eco-steve 05:14 PM 2/3/09

   Perhaps I am stupid, but I fail to see how Markey graphs relate to fractal theory. To obtain a fractal pattern write a very concise algorythm which is self-referential and recursive. Market curves are governed by Chaos Theory, as there are too many unknowns for initial values to be significant. Introduce randomness to a fractal curve and you get nonsense on the screen. Fractals are totally predictable, even if writing them is a logical nightmare.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

4. 4. nimajha 09:24 AM 7/15/09

   Do you think it is possible?
   
   This guy Anthony claims to have a formula
   to turn&
   
   $1000 into $1 million in roughly 5 years.
   Or $2000 into $1.7 million in just 1.9 years!
   
   I'm not sure...
   But this guy shows you a video where
   he is actually doing it.
   
   And he does it so effortlessly and explains
   it all, as he goes along.
   
   Watch this video and decide yourself&
   
   http://www.2stocktrading.com/offer5.html
   
   This type of quick cash injection...
   Should be ILLEGAL!

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

5. 5. pennystocks 02:40 AM 7/1/10

   Anyone who is an investor or who plans to invest some of their money in the market always has one question on their mind: What are the good <a href="http://www.stocktrains.com"> Penny Stocks </a>
   out there? You see people making lots of cash by putting their money into the companies they believe in, but not all of these companies are publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange or on NASDAQ.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

6. 6. markettips1 in reply to eco-steve 08:06 AM 7/19/10

   
   
   Investing is a quite a complex exercise. But when it comes to Indian stock market the basic principles, they are amazingly simple. Anyone can become good investor and reach your goals just by following those simple and easy rules. Here is the list of few <a href="http://www.sharetipsexpert.com">Indian stock market tips</a> rules for making investment in mutual funds:
   Be a long-term investor: Start Early: Know yourself and then What You Are Buying: Be A Disciplined Investor:
   
   Alternately people may also trade in <a href="http://www.sharetipsexpert.com/Commodity_trading_tips.aspx">MCX tips</a> . Client may also trade in nifty and make good money from free <a href="http://www.sharetipsexpert.com/news1.aspx?id=24">nifty trading tips</a> available online.

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

7. 7. RBIDDLE 10:13 PM 7/21/10

   DOES ANYONE KNOW OF AN ARTICLE ABOUT TRADING THE MARKET VIA FIBONACCI THAT I FOUND IN SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, I THINK, BACK IN THE MID 80S PRIOR TO THE CRASH IN '87?

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

8. 8. mariasharapova844 05:24 AM 8/4/10

   <a href="http://www.livestockauction.org" rel="dofollow">Stock Chart</a>
   I am stupid, but I fail to see how Markey graphs relate to fractal theory

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

9. 9. robbinsmith 09:58 PM 8/5/10

   <a href="http://www.forexaddicts.com/" rel="dofollow">Stock Analysis</a>

   Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

10. 10. altondelmote 12:45 AM 10/21/10

    The Market was hemorrhaging like a stuck pig, and nobody had a clue how to stop it, resulting in complete financial free-fall.
    
    Thanks
    www.pennyinvest.com

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

11. 11. sharetipsinfo 05:29 AM 11/15/10

    Hi,
    Seems like it’s a nice blog. So let us also add something useful in it. <a href="http://www.sharetipsinfo.com" title="Trading"> Trading </a>in volatile market can be very fruitful also if we follow technical levels closely. It’s a common saying that stock market can change fortune in either way. But now the question is how to earn money from the Indian stock market.
    
    Traders are advised to strictly follow technical analyses and investors can follow fundamental analysis. Many analysts say it’s not wise to follow technical and fundamental analysis together. But we say what the problem is if one does so? As more knowledge will add up things will not have any negative impact.
    
    Regards
    . <a href="http://www.sharetipsinfo.com" title="Sharetipsinfo Team">Sharetipsinfo Team</a>
    

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

12. 12. kanikapatel11 08:01 AM 7/4/11

    hi Gary Stix, Seems like it’s a nice blog. So let us also add something useful in it. Trading in volatile market can be very fruitful also if we follow technical levels closely. It’s a common saying that stock market can change fortune in either way. But now the question is how to earn money from the Indian stock market.
    
    Traders are advised to strictly follow technical analyses and investors can follow fundamental analysis. Many analysts say it’s not wise to follow technical and fundamental analysis together. But we say what the problem is if one does so? As more knowledge will add up things will not have any negative impact. REgards: http://www.iasr.in/

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

13. 13. devangvisaria 05:53 AM 8/26/11

    You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.
    
    Thanks & regards,
    http://www.devangvisaria.com

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

14. 14. robertdavis 05:46 AM 9/3/11

    Thanks for this good one.....
    
    
    http://www.chasingbeta.com/

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

15. 15. GilBurt 06:08 AM 11/1/11

    The basic principles of Indian stock market is very simple. Anyone can become good investor and reach your goals just following this rules.
    
    http://www.otcmarketalerts.com/

    Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this