More 60-Second Science
The last time you splurged on a live lobster for dinner, you might not have given any thought to how much the little guy was going to suffer as he boiled to death. Until recently many researchers believed the crustacean nervous system too primitive to process pain. But scientists at Queen's University in Belfast now think that crustaceans may be more sensitive to pain than previously thought.
The researchers used crabs as their test animals. And they found that crabs that experienced an electric shock when they hid under a safe, dark rock would eventually learn to avoid the hiding place. And that avoidance is key: the animals’ ability to remember the unpleasant shock and avoid it is consistent with the ability to feel and remember pain. If the behavior was merely a reflex, the critters would continue to visit the shelter.
The study is in the Journal of Experimental Biology. [Barry Magee and Robert W. Elwood, Shock avoidance by discrimination learning in the shore crab (Carcinus maenas) is consistent with a key criterion for pain] [Also see Nicola Stead, Painful Feelings in Crabs]
The situation is likely the same with lobsters. So before you break out the bibs and melted butter, it might be nice to put your future dinner on a little anesthetic ice.
—Gretchen Cuda Kroen
[The above text is a transcript of this podcast.]



Listen to this Podcast
See what we're tweeting about




2 Comments
Add CommentAm I wrong in my impression that "Experiencing Pain" is different from respondent conditioning? When we use the word "experience" are we not talking about some level of awareness? Are you suggesting that the crab is "remembering" a negative experience?
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisAwareness may be a property of something material or it may be an output of a neurological circuit or it may be inherent in all life. This experiment suggests that crabs are aware.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisWhich is more likely: the crab seems to be aware but isn't or seems to be aware and is?
I know what an electric shock feels like. Is what I feel, the same as what the crab feels? If so, then senses and awareness only require a simple crab brain. A human brain is complex for reasons other than creating the sense of shock.
In humans the process of awareness is hidden in a complex brain. Perhaps, awareness will be easier to isolate in a crab's brain.