



Buddhists across Asia release wildlife as a show of compassion, but conservationists find that the practice tortures the animals and may impact threatened species
By Rachel Nuwer | August 1, 2012 | 4
Vendors in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, gather at a popular Buddhist temple to sell offerings, including live birds for merit releases. Over the course of a year, a quarter of a million birds representing 57 different species pass through these cages in Phnom Penh alone, according to a new study....[More]
Vendors in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, gather at a popular Buddhist temple to sell offerings, including live birds for merit releases. Over the course of a year, a quarter of a million birds representing 57 different species pass through these cages in Phnom Penh alone, according to a new study. [Less] [Link to this slide]
Cages of two by two-by 1.5 feet are crammed with 200 to 300 birds destined for merit releases at the start of each day. This cage from Phnom Penh is dominated by scaly-breasted munias and Eurasian tree sparrows, with a few streaked weavers and plain-backed sparrows thrown in....[More]
Cages of two by two-by 1.5 feet are crammed with 200 to 300 birds destined for merit releases at the start of each day. This cage from Phnom Penh is dominated by scaly-breasted munias and Eurasian tree sparrows, with a few streaked weavers and plain-backed sparrows thrown in. The stressful conditions suppress the birds’ immune systems, meaning they are more likely to catch diseases and less likely to survive after being released. [Less] [Link to this slide]
Birds used in merit releases are usually sourced from the wild. Farmers and hunters set up traps in their rice fields and in forests to catch the birds each day....[More]
Birds used in merit releases are usually sourced from the wild. Farmers and hunters set up traps in their rice fields and in forests to catch the birds each day. Snare traps are one of the most common methods used and can be easily fashioned from a bit of string and bamboo or reed. The traps are set up on bird trails in fields or forests, and when the animal passes through, the string catches and tightens around its neck like a noose, holding it alive until the hunter comes to collect it. Here, a Vietnamese farmer demonstrates how to set up one of the homemade contraptions. [Less] [Link to this slide]
The same Vietnamese farmer who demonstrated the snare trap shares his latest catch, a greater coucal. Since the bird is still alive, he will likely sell it to a trader who will then take the animal to a market, restaurant or temple in Ca Mau, the closest city....[More]
The same Vietnamese farmer who demonstrated the snare trap shares his latest catch, a greater coucal. Since the bird is still alive, he will likely sell it to a trader who will then take the animal to a market, restaurant or temple in Ca Mau, the closest city. If the captured bird was sick or already dead, the farmer more than likely would have taken it home to feed his own family. [Less] [Link to this slide]
Kelly Edmunds, a researcher at the University of East Anglia in England who investigates the bird trade in Asia, says many people collect birds out of genuine love for the animals....[More]
Kelly Edmunds, a researcher at the University of East Anglia in England who investigates the bird trade in Asia, says many people collect birds out of genuine love for the animals. At this home in rural Vietnam, a man keeps wild-caught purple swamphens in his backyard because of their beautiful plumage colors. [Less] [Link to this slide]
Recently trapped wild birds of all shapes and sizes await the arrival of a motorbike trader who will transfer them to markets, shops or restaurants in nearby Ca Mau....[More]
Recently trapped wild birds of all shapes and sizes await the arrival of a motorbike trader who will transfer them to markets, shops or restaurants in nearby Ca Mau. Although the trade and sale of any wild bird is illegal in Vietnam, authorities almost always turn a blind eye. These cages are clearly visible from the road. [Less] [Link to this slide]
Traders collect birds from the countryside and often deliver them to shops like this one in Hanoi. The shop owner displays her chirping goods in neat rows outside....[More]
Traders collect birds from the countryside and often deliver them to shops like this one in Hanoi. The shop owner displays her chirping goods in neat rows outside. Within such shops, however, animals often must endure poor conditions. Stacks upon stacks of overcrowded cages are kept in the dark, with feces and feather dust raining down from the birds above to those below. [Less] [Link to this slide]
A live finch, sold as a charm in Shanghai. Wild birds are commonly sold throughout Southeast Asia, China, Taiwan and South Korea.
[Link to this slide]
A trader’s motorbike idles at a Buddhist temple in Vietnam. As soon as a seller’s cage of merit release birds begins to thin out, such a trader shows up with a newly stocked one....[More]
A trader’s motorbike idles at a Buddhist temple in Vietnam. As soon as a seller’s cage of merit release birds begins to thin out, such a trader shows up with a newly stocked one. Traders often lurk near the site of merit releases in order to scoop up newly released, disoriented birds and start the cycle all over again. [Less] [Link to this slide]
A Vietnamese man offers a cage of birds their freedom in exchange for good karma in this merit release ritual. On religious holidays, sellers report a 100-percent turnover of their birds and say upwards of 80 percent are sold on normal days....[More]
A Vietnamese man offers a cage of birds their freedom in exchange for good karma in this merit release ritual. On religious holidays, sellers report a 100-percent turnover of their birds and say upwards of 80 percent are sold on normal days. But the released birds are often recaptured shortly thereafter or are left in a debilitated state that jeopardizes their survival. [Less] [Link to this slide]
YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the one-year subscription.
Origins: Going Back to Where the Story Really Starts
12 Events That Will Change Everything
YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the one-year subscription.
4 Comments
Add Comment'may' and 'could'? Junk science. I call shenanigans and come back when there's actual concrete evidence. Too much emphasis on issues on the basis of 'maybe's' and enough is enough.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisNot just Asia.Atlantic lobsters now breeding in Pacific Ocean near Vancouver are thought to have been introduced by this 'merit' chasing.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisThis just in: Homo Sapiens living on Earth MAY add to 'non-natural' polution of planet. All humans urged to commit suicide on the possibility this MIGHT be true.
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to thisSomebody needs to talk to the people ineffectively trying to save the gharials with the wisdom in these words.....
Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this"Gilbert imagines programs forged between researchers and Buddhist communities in which declining native species are captive-bred and then released by practitioners. The Society for Conservation Biology and Buddhist communities are already exploring initial ways of doing this."
While I don't imagine releasing gharials per se, I can imagine turning to local people and training them to nurture the species, and in return being allowed to harvest some of what they raise to sell to make money to survive instead of the current system where all contact is illegal.