# Polynomial Plot: Simple Math Expressions Yield Intricate Visual Patterns [Slide Show]

Plotting the roots of run-of-the-mill polynomials yields dazzling results

• Share
• Email
•  1 of 7

Dan Christensen, a mathematician at the University of Western Ontario, plotted the roots of polynomials of degree six or less whose coefficients are integers between –4 and 4....[More]

This crop of the previous slide reveals details of the hole near i on the vertical (imaginary) axis, which appears at the top center of the image and in greater detail in the inset....[More]

Sam Derbyshire, an undergraduate student at the University of Warwick in England, took a large but very specific set of polynomials to make this rich plot, comprising hundreds of millions of individual roots....[More]

Derbyshire's image of 24th-degree polynomial roots with coefficients of either 1 or –1 features a serrated hole around the root 1. The white line slicing through the image traces the horizontal (or real) axis—the line comprises the real roots of the polynomials....[More]

This crop of Derbyshire's image shows intriguing patterns around the imaginary number i, the square root of –1.

[Link to this slide]
SAM DERBYSHIRE

Around the number 4/5, a white line again traces the real axis—Derbyshire's polynomials have a seemingly continuous collection of real roots in the vicinity....[More]

This crop shows the detail of an inner edge of the main ring in Derbyshire's image. It is a favorite of John Baez, a mathematical physicist at the University of California, Riverside, who posted these images on his Web site ....[More]

YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the one-year subscription.

ADVERTISEMENT

### 23 Comments

Add Comment
View
1. 1. fb36 10:30 AM 12/28/09

Polynomials solved by Newton's method produce even more complex patterns:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton_fractal

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
2. 2. rollingf 02:13 PM 12/28/09

While these plots, in general, are pretty, they are the basis for finding the broadcast pattern for radio (and TV) towers. Complex numbers may seem imaginary, but the signal you receive on your radio, TV, or wireless device are real.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
3. 3. pramodbhai 12:22 AM 12/29/09

I wonder if the structure of the atom or the Universe is not hidden in such formulae. As if the GOD unleashed a formula and things then took their own inevitable course. It will be great if like God Particle, we can also unravel God formula.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
4. 4. pramodbhai 12:27 AM 12/29/09

I wonder if the structure of atom or the universe is hidden in some such formulae or the formula. AS if the God unleashed such a formula and things then took their inevitable course from there on. It would be interesting if like God particle, the God formula too can be uncovered (in terms of our maths).

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
5. 5. Willington 04:59 AM 12/29/09

I retired from teaching Mathematics two years ago. I WANT TO GO BACK!

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
6. 6. Ahmadu in reply to pramodbhai 06:54 AM 12/29/09

It is very likely but try to consider reading the Quran it is very scientific it contains alot of recently establish theories about space and planets is mentioned in the Quran which was revealed 14 centuries ago. The 19th coeficient partern may reveal something to do with our solar system or universe or multiverse.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
7. 7. Schiaf 08:19 AM 12/29/09

I have no idea what on earth this article is talking about, but dang, "the sharply defined figures looming from the mist" sure are pretty.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
8. 8. Carlton22 09:37 AM 12/29/09

The esoteric meaning of the word GOD is Geometry of Divinity. The Golden Ratio is found throughout nature and is most beautifully displayed in the spiral shell of the Nautilus.

"In the 1960s and '70s Swiss engineer and medical doctor Hans Jenny performed experiments using sound frequencies on various materials such as water, sand, dust, liquid plastic and milk.

Dr Jenny placed the material on a metal plate attached to a crystal oscillator which was controlled by a frequency generator capable of producing a wide range of vibrations. He then filmed and photographed what happened on the plate.

He coined the term Cymatics (the study of wave-form phenomena), which is derived from the Greek 'kyma' meaning 'wave', and 'ta kymatica' meaning 'matters pertaining to waves'."

You can see Dr Jenny and his device along with some pictures of the resulting phenomena at this link http://www.unitedearth.com.au/sound.html including the Sri Yantra (composed of 9 ascending and descending isosceles triangles) that formed when the OM was intoned.

You can look at a current You Tube video of the same type of experiments based on Dr Jenny's work at this link http://curezone.org/forums/fm.asp?i=862325.

Dr. Emoto did experiments with the effects on water of spoken and written words, sounds, and music. He would then freeze samples of the water and observe the crystalline structures that formed. You can see some of the results at these links http://enwaterment.com/ and http://www.life-enthusiast.com/twilight/research_emoto.htm.

All of Creation is formed of God's Light, Energy and Consciousness and has Innate Intelligence. We were created in the image and likeness of God and within our Heart of hearts God placed an Unfed Threefold Flame of Power (blue, Father), Wisdom (yellow, Son) and Love (pink, Holy Spirit) that bursts forth from a Cube of White Fire (Mother). This Threefold Flame is our connection point to our divinity and it is the portal to the kingdom of God that Jesus said was within us. This is the access point to the Higher Mind, the Christ Mind that St Paul admonished us to put on. This is the source of the "still small voice of conscience". For more, visit my blog at http://carltonnewman.blogspot.com.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
9. 9. jstreet 12:40 PM 12/29/09

We don't need to wax mystical to appreciate the beauty of mathematical images (sometimes called geometry) but it is a very old and natural human response. From the beginning, mathematicians have "seen" the beauty of nature through the medium of mathematical symbols and geometrical patterns. Plato was the first philosopher, whose works we posses, to build a philosophy around mathematics. His philosophy is, essentially, an ecstatic, mystical song of thanks for the mind's capacity to discover patterns which exist in nature and which are not simply inventions. We rationalists celebrate that which seems to be a "gift from God" but which is really simply our ability to discover and show others these deep and beautiful patterns that are the heart of nature. Our happiness is so great, sometimes, that we can't stop ourselves from singing and shouting with words like God, truth and beauty .... when the simple word "mathematics" does not seem adequate ...

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
10. 10. cc_ctc 02:24 PM 12/29/09

Seeing as we are all being very esoteric I shall offer up some thoughts. It is clear that the universe has a superlative regularity both at the level of the galaxy and the natural world on this planet, thus dear Paul Davies has us all heading towards the "God" factor. What this mapping of the maths shows though is that the universe gets a bit lost at the square root of -1 and goes into a bit of a tizz, seemingly losing data around it like a black hole, a bit like the Hollywood robot "this does not compute". Maybe when trying to equate the quantum levels with the macro we should be trying to find a theory of everything that involves a theory of non-compliance rather than unification. Thus the universe in its majesty makes it all work like clockwork by having a system of things that don't compute, such as in brutal nature of the natural world, or as at the level of genes, or the edge of the universe, and quantum factors. It isn't a perfect universe, just a clever one. Can anyone work that bit out, the bit that looks and has a design which appears as though it isn't computing because it won't, so that is how the rest of it DOES work elegantly? Does that help- "God" as a trickster? Better call it the theory of implausibility or universal non-compliance rather than unified theory. We are looking in the wrong direction for the answers perhaps.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
11. 11. scohn 06:15 PM 12/29/09

The graphics are lovely but I would LOVE to know the "Simple Polynomial" that each is a plot of and what graphing method was used.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
12. 12. fb36 in reply to scohn 07:27 PM 12/29/09

scohn,
These images are not plot of a single polynomial. Also the polynomials here are calculated using complex number arithmetic formulas; not usual real number math.
See here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_numbers
I think there are multiple known methods for solving complex number based polynomials. You would need to write a computer program to generate all possible polynomials, and solve all of them and plot all roots (each x,y) to replicate these images.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
13. 13. pramodbhai 12:09 AM 12/30/09

I, at least, did not mention God in any religious sense. It only stands for an unimaginable indescribable root of everything, for want of a more appropriate word in my limited vocabulary. I was just curious if with some basic building blocks (in the language of our physics), their unique values and their organization by means of some such basic formulae, (in the language of our mathematics) the world as we know as of now can be plausibly explained and then extrapolated to what it will be. I humbly suggest that we appreciate that we will be like one of those seven blind men exploring elephant and also accept that we may fall into the "king has no clothes" syndrome while not challenging the prevailing wisdom. As they say, what we like is not necessarily good, what we believe in is not necessarily true and that all questions are open. Havel or is it Gide , has said that befriend those seeking the truth, not the ones who have found it.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
14. 14. Befell in reply to cc_ctc 05:40 AM 12/30/09

Dear cc_ctc,

Nice to see a sober [? - no need for a literally zero blood-alcohol level ;)], realistic, non-religious, hyper-realistic perspective; one offering a realistically messy, smeared-out, (not pedantic but prudent and plausible) philosophical position) on What Is going on.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
15. 15. Fabrice LOTY 01:16 PM 12/30/09

Thinking polynomial roots may conceal some secret code is not the smart thing to do. Obviously, beauty, love, and justice are hardly understandable through mere numbers. There should be a superset to science.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
16. 16. verdai 07:21 PM 12/30/09

well,
where are the fractals
hiding super dimensions -

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
17. 17. verdai 07:34 PM 12/30/09

that last slide does look pretty confused/ing -
in contrast to the others
all that amorphous cloudy black fog back from the edge within the border,
who said that?

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
18. 18. anchorite in reply to Willington 08:22 PM 12/30/09

Willington at 04:59 AM on 12/29/09 WROTE.....
I retired from teaching Mathematics two years ago. I WANT TO GO BACK!

Willington...i say "GO BACK YOUNG MAN!!!!!"...my Father began working as a consultant when he was 72...went on do many great and wonderful things. Happiest years of his life...great thoughts...extraordinary friendships and time to contemplate the universe in the company of the young.
It was a fascinating thing to see...just like these images!

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
19. 19. justjustinharries 04:07 AM 12/31/09

Patterns are nice, but which equations yield true non-patterns? True spontaneity or chance patterns?

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
20. 20. Fabrice LOTY in reply to verdai 10:17 AM 12/31/09

Concerning Fractals-
Specific geometry may help understand phenomenons beyond our natural intuition. Still, such mathematical tools are merely functional, not charged with ultimate significance.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
21. 21. LocoMotives 10:47 AM 12/31/09

That's way more interesting than when I had to find poles and zeros for control systems using Laplace transforms and a slide rule. The detail is probably more due to the floating point representation than the polynomial itself, but my 12" slide rule only had 3 sig figs.

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
22. 22. roberoy 03:18 PM 1/1/10

Does anyone think that there is a similarity here with FRACTALS or CHAOS?

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this
23. 23. Flatlander 11:28 AM 1/22/10

I like pi

Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this

### Add a Comment

You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment.
Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account.
Advertisement

X

### Give a Gift & Get a Gift - Free!

Give a 1 year subscription as low as \$14.99

X

X

### Account Linking

###### Welcome, . Do you have an existing ScientificAmerican.com account?

Yes, please link my existing account with for quick, secure access.

No, I would like to create a new account with my profile information.

X

Are you sure?

X

### Institutional Access

It has been identified that the institution you are trying to access this article from has institutional site license access to Scientific American on nature.com. To access this article in its entirety through site license access, click below.

X

X

X