Won't the- 'Scientific American give its opinion of the practicability-ofaspeakragte- legraph 1 How far caHla good pair of bi: make themselves heard ' through a- tube of: half inch diameter (or an inch if' it would be better 1) The advantages of such a telegraph are too numerous to mentionwhat' are the difficulties 1Savannah Journal. We know of no difculties in the way of the speaking telegraph, except the expense ,of the lines; they cannot be erected' so cheaply astelegraph wires, nor can tl.ey 'be operated so rapidly. The' eJl;treme distance 'through which twq individuals can comniupicate through a tube, we do not know, nor do we believe experiments have ever been' n:iade on a scale sufficient to test the question.' For short distances- through public' buildings they operate, well, and are in general use, but for public use they are far inferior to the electric telegraph. ' Gutta percha tubes would be the best and cheapest to use for long distances. We lire of opinion,, however, that the accous- tic telegraph is not so much employed as it might be, especially on shipboard, in prisons, hospitals, asylums, 'c.
This article was originally published with the title "Acoustic Telegraph" in Scientific American 8, 13, 104 (December 1852)
doi:10.1038/scientificamerican12111852-104a