Have you spent time this summer spinning a Hula-Hoop around your waist or arm? Could you do it easily or was it difficult? Have you ever wondered how Hula-Hoops work or what makes them able to spin around a person's waist or arm—seeming to defy gravity? The answer can be explained by physics, which can help you determine what makes an effective Hula-Hoop. In this activity you'll get to create your own Hula-Hoops and investigate how their weights affect how they spin. Which do you think will spin better, a heavy hoop or a lighter one? Get ready to do some hula-hooping to find out!
What makes a Hula-Hoop spin around a person's waist? It comes down to a combination of several factors. Every object has weight, which pulls it down towards the ground. In order to lift something up off the ground, you need to exert an upward force (a push or a pull). In order to make something spin you need to exert a push or pull that creates a torque (such as when you twist a doorknob). So, to make a hula hoop spin and stay up in the air, you need to exert an upward force and a torque with your hips. Another force involved in the Hula-Hooping process is friction, the force resisting two surfaces sliding against each other. For example, if you push a book and let it slide across a table, it will slow to a stop due to friction. If you want it to keep moving, you have to keep pushing it. Similarly friction between the hoop and the hula-hooper's clothes and the air will cause the hoop’s spinning to slow down. To keep it in the air you have to keep spinning it and pushing it up. Friction, however, also helps prevent the hoop from sliding downward when it’s in contact with your hips.
That might sound like a lot of complicated physics for a toy, but don’t worry! You will do some hula-hooping in this project and explore for yourself. How do you think the hoop's weight affects how it spins?
• Tape measure
• PVC cutter (preferred), or a sharp cutter knife or some other type of cutter that can safely cut through polypipe
• Polypipe, which is hard black tubing usually used for irrigation (five-eighth, three-quarter or one-inch diameter, about 25 feet in length, although it normally comes in rolls of 100 feet). Available from a garden supply or home improvement store.
• Poly insert coupling or wooden dowel that fits snugly inside of the polypipe tubing. For example, if you are using three-quarter-inch tubing, you will want to use a three-quarter-inch poly insert coupling. This should also be available from a garden supply or home improvement store.
• Hair dryer
• Wide plastic tape such as duct tape
• One cup of sand
• Measuring cup
• Funnel with an opening that can fit into the polypipe or a thick sheet of paper and tape
• Bucket (optional)
• Timer or stopwatch
• Adult helper
• Another helper to assist in testing the Hula-Hoops (optional)
• Measure the height from the ground to somewhere between the hula-hooper's navel and the middle of their chest. This will be the height (or diameter) of the hoop.
• To figure out the length of polypipe you want to cut to make your Hula-Hoop, take the number you just measured and multiply it by pi (3.14). (The circumference of a circle equals pi times the circle's diameter.)
• Measure the length of polypipe needed and have an adult carefully cut the tubing at the right spot using a PVC cutter or sharp cutter knife.
• Use a poly insert coupling (or wooden dowel) to connect the ends of the tubing so they form a circle. If it's a tight fit, use the hair dryer to warm the tubing ends (one at a time) for about two minutes before inserting the coupling inside of the tubing. Insert the coupling in one end of the tubing until the coupling is about halfway inserted, then insert the other half of the coupling into the tubing's other free end. Push the tubing together until little (or no) coupling is visible, using the hair dryer to heat the tubing if it is difficult to insert the coupling.
• Put a short strip of wide plastic tape over the connection where the two ends of tubing meet.
• Follow this process to make a second Hula-Hoop that is the same size, but this time add one cup of sand to the tube (to increase its weight) before connecting the ends with the poly insert coupling. To add the sand, use a funnel to carefully pour the sand into the tubing. You may want to do this over a bucket and/or have a helper assist with this. (You should pour any spilled sand into the tubing.) If you do not have a funnel, you can make one by rolling a thick sheet of paper into a cone shape with a hole at the end, fastening it with tape. When you're done making both Hula-Hoops, how do they feel compared with one another?
• Now you will do some hula-hooping with your homemade Hula-Hoops. If you need directions or tips on how to hula-hoop, you can watch an instructional video online, such as this one .
• Pick up the lighter two Hula-Hoops to try first.
• Have one person (yourself or a helper) hula-hoop with it around their waist while a helper starts timing the hula-hooper as soon as they reach a steady pace. Have the helper time the person for one minute and count how many full turns the hoop makes during that time. If the hooper cannot hoop through the full minute with the Hula-Hoop, try starting over again or try collecting data for only 30 seconds. How many times could the hula-hooper spin the lighter hoop in a minute? How well could the hooper spin it around? Does it seem awkward or does it spin well?
• Repeat this process with the heavier Hula-Hoop, again timing how many spins the hula-hooper can do in one minute. (Make sure the hooper doesn't change clothes while collecting data.) Did the hula-hooper spin the heavier hoop faster or slower than the lighter one? Why do you think this is? Did this hoop feel more or less awkward to spin, or about the same as the other hoop?
• Which Hula-Hoop spun faster, the lighter or heavier one? Was the faster Hula-Hoop also the one that was the easiest to spin, once it got going?
• If you want, you can repeat this process a few more times for each Hula-Hoop. Are your results consistent?
• For even more data, the hula-hooper and helper can switch roles and repeat this process for both Hula-Hoops. Did the other person get similar results?
• Extra: In this activity you compared Hula-Hoops that were the same size but had different weights. You could repeat this activity again, but this time make Hula-Hoops of different sizes. Tip: The smallest Hula-Hoop should have a diameter up to the hula-hooper's navel, and the largest should have a diameter to the middle of their chest. How does the size of the Hula-Hoop affect how it spins?
• Extra: You could make a broader range of Hula-Hoops, such as by adding different amounts of sand and/or making several different sizes. Is there a relationship between speed, the weight and/or size of the Hula-Hoop? If so, what is it?
• Extra: Try hula-hooping in different types of clothes. Do different garments affect the speed at which the Hula-Hoop rotates? Can you correlate your results to the force of friction?
Observations and results
Did the heavier Hula-Hoop spin slower than the lighter one? Was it harder to spin the heavier Hula-Hoop for a long time than it was to spin the lighter one?
The Hula-Hoop with sand added to it should have clearly felt heavier than the hoop that held no sand. Because of its greater weight, the heavier hoop was pulled down more as it was spun around in the air. The hula-hooper probably felt a need to work harder to keep the heavier hoop up and spinning, and it might have even been difficult to keep it at waist level for more than 30 seconds. The heavier hoop probably spun much slower than the lighter one (such as around 60 to 70 turns per minute for the heavier hoop compared with 100 to 120 turns per minute for the lighter one), although there can be a lot of variability, depending on the hula-hooper and the hoops.
More to explore
The Hooper versus Gravity, from Hooping.org
How Hula-Hoops Work, from Hooping.org
Hula-Hoop Physics, from Meggan Irving and Richard Barrans, University of Wyoming
Motion Mania: Applying Physics to Hula-Hooping, from Science Buddies
This activity brought to you in partnership with Science Buddies