**Key Concepts**

Mathematics

Addition

Counting

Puzzles

**Introduction**

Do you ever use math as a tool to solve interesting problems? In the 1970s math was often taught with simple worksheets. One teacher was looking for a way to help his students have more fun with math and logic. So he developed what is now known as the perimeter magic triangle puzzles. Try them out—and have some fun as you start thinking about counting in a whole new way!

**Background**

Counting is so common that we forget how it is connected to the broader area of mathematics that studies numbers, known as arithmetic. We can see counting as repeatedly adding one: when you add one object to another you have two objects. Add one more and you have three, and so on. Addition is the process of adding numbers. The result of the addition is called the sum. With smaller numbers you might use counting to find the sum. When you have three and want to add two, for example, you can count two numbers beyond three to get to five. With plenty of practice you can often memorize the sums of the numbers one through 10—at which point in can be fun to play with numbers to find all the ways you can make a particular sum.

Math puzzles and games can be a fun way to get practice working with numbers. Puzzles also provide entertaining ways to build strategic and logical thinking. With a little trial and error you can often start to find new strategies to complete a puzzle faster. These are the very same techniques mathematicians use: starting small and trying to find patterns in the sequence of answers. These patterns are then used to predict the answers to even bigger puzzles.

If this is all too abstract, try the puzzle presented in this activity! It might make the process of learning arithmetic clear.

**Materials**

- Two sheets of 9 by 12-inch paper, such as construction or craft paper (if possible, choose contrasting colors)
- Pencil or marker
- Ruler
- Scissors
- A quarter or other round object of similar size
- 21 pennies, small blocks or other small stackable objects
- More sheets of paper (optional)

**Preparation**

- Draw a large triangle on a sheet of paper (you can use a ruler to help make straight lines).
- Use a quarter to trace a circle on each corner of the triangle. Now trace a circle onto the middle of each side of the triangle. You should have six circles.
- On the bottom of the second sheet of paper draw six circles similar in size to the ones drawn on the triangle.
- Cut out these circles, and number them 1 through 6. These circles will be referred to as number disks.
- Keep the top part of the second sheet of paper. You will use it to write down your results.

**Procedure**

- On the paper with the triangle use the 21 pennies to build towers on each circle. Each circle must have at least 1 penny, but no two towers can be of the same height.
*Can you do it?* - Keep trying until you find a solution!
- Count the number of pennies in each tower. Write down each sum in order from the smallest to the largest number.
*What do you notice about this set of numbers?* - Shift the towers around or rebuild them until you can fulfill one more requirement: The total number of pennies used to build the three towers on each side of the triangle must be the same. If you build towers of 1, 5 and 3 pennies in the circles lining up on one side of the triangle, for example, you used 1 + 5 + 3 = 9 pennies on that side. Lining up towers of 1, 2 and 4 pennies on the adjacent side would not work because 1+ 2 + 4 = 7 —not 9 like the first side. (Notice the tower of 1 penny was placed on the corner of this triangle, so it contributes to two sides.) If you tried 1, 2 and 6 for the adjacent side instead, that works because 1 + 2 + 6 = 9. Now you can place the one tower that is left and check if 9 pennies are used in the three towers on the third side of this triangle. Try it out!
*Did you find a solution?* - If this is not a solution, think.
*Can you rearrange a few towers and get a solution?* - If working with abstract numbers is easier for you, replace the towers with the number disks. Each number disks then represents a tower of pennies. The number written on the number disks informs you of the number of pennies in that tower.
- Using 9 pennies per side is possible!
*Did you find the solution? Are there several ways you can arrange the towers so there are 9 pennies used per side?* *Can you arrange the pennies so you use 10, 11 or even 12 pennies per side?***Extra**: Show that there are no solutions that use 8 or fewer pennies per side—or show that there are no solutions with a total of 13 or more pennies per side.**Extra**: The puzzle presented in this activity is called a “perimeter magic triangle of order three.” To extend it to a higher-order perimeter magic triangle start by drawing a new triangle. Add circles on the corners like you did the first time, but this time add two more circles on each side in between the corners. For this puzzle you will need nine number disks. Number them 1 through 9. Just like in the previous puzzle you need to find ways to place the disks on the circles so the sums of the numbers on each side of this triangle are identical. Mathematicians call this triangle a triangle of order four as it has four numbers on each side. Once you have solved this puzzle continue with a triangle of order five (add three more circles between the corners and cut 12 number disks), then order six, and so on.**Extra**: Can you create a strategy to find solutions for this type of puzzle quickly?

**Observations and Results**

Did you find that you can only arrange the 21 pennies in towers of 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 pennies if you need to make six towers of different heights? Could you come up with ways to arrange the towers so the sum of pennies used on each side of the triangle is identical for all three sides? It is possible for a total of 9, 10, 11, and 12 pennies per side.

To use a total of 9 pennies on each side, you place the towers with 1, 2, and 3 pennies on the corners of the triangle. The tower of 6 pennies goes in between the towers of 1 and 2 pennies because 1 + 2 + 6 = 9. The tower of 5 pennies stands between the tower of 1 and the tower of 3 pennies, as 1 + 3 + 5 also equals 9. The towers with 2, 4 and 3 pennies fill up the third row. Notice how the smallest towers are placed on the corners for this solution.

To arrange the towers so that you use 12 pennies on each side start by arranging the tallest towers (those with 6, 5 and 4 pennies) on the corners of your triangle and fill in the circles in between. Place the smallest tower you have left (1 penny tall) in between the two tallest towers (5 and 6 pennies each). Do you see that the smallest one you are left with (2 pennies tall) goes in between the tallest ones that need a tower in between (the towers with 6 and 4 pennies each)?

A strategy you could use to find the solution that has 10 pennies on each side is listing all the ways you can make 10 by adding three different numbers. You will find 3 + 2 + 5 = 10, 5 + 4 + 1 = 10, and 1 + 6 + 3 = 10. Can you see that 3, 5 and 1 are part of two of these sums? This means these go on the corners of your triangle. You can use the same strategy to find out how to place the pennies so there are 11 or 12 pennies used on each side.

Are you wondering how you can know that using 8 pennies per side is not possible? With 8 pennies per side you use 3 X 8, or 24, pennies for the triangle. Because you reuse the pennies on the corner towers you at most use 1 + 2 + 3 (the sum of the three smallest towers) or 6 pennies fewer. In other words you can use at most 18 pennies. The puzzle asks you to use 21.

**More to Explore**

Perimeter Magic Triangles, from Magic Squares

The Tower of Hanoi, from *Scientific American*

Statistical Science: Melt-in-Your-Mouth Math, from *Scientific American*

STEM Activities for Kids, from Science Buddies

*This activity brought to you in partnership with Science Buddies*