US lawmakers have taken a significant step towards averting a global crisis in helium supply, thanks to a bill passed by the House of Representatives on 26 April. If it passes the Senate and becomes law, the bill would delay the imminent closure of the world’s only strategic helium reserve. It would also increase the price of the gas from the reserve, so helium-dependent researchers and industry could still face ballooning costs. However, the prospect of higher prices is encouraging the development of new helium sources in Qatar and Russia, which may ultimately lead to a more stable helium market.
With a boiling point of 4 kelvin — lower than that of any other element — liquid helium has many uses, including cooling the superconducting magnets in medical imaging scanners. The semiconductor industry also relies on the inert gas to shield delicate crystals from contaminants during manufacturing.
Demand is on the rise. More than 100 million cubic meters of helium is extracted from natural gas worldwide every year, yet meeting global needs requires a further 60 million cubic meters a year from the US Federal Helium Reserve, a vast geological reservoir near Amarillo, Texas, that stores helium from past gas extraction (see ‘Floating skyward’).
SOURCE: USGS/R. Clarke
In the mid-1990s, the reserve boasted 1 billion cubic meters of the gas — and a debt of US$1.3 billion accrued after a large buy-up of helium in the 1960s. Over time, the simple formula used to calculate the price of helium sold from the reserve has failed to keep pace with commercial prices. In 1996, appalled that the government was undercutting a booming commercial gas market, lawmakers passed the Helium Privatization Act. Its goal was to sell the helium reserve to pay off the debt. Once the debt was gone, no more helium would be sold. “They would literally turn off the tap,” says Richard Clarke, a process and resources consultant based in Oxford, UK. The shutdown was expected by October this year. And because the reserve’s cut-rate prices had dissuaded companies from developing sources elsewhere, a supply shortage was possible. “The Privatization Act has come back to bite them,” says Clarke.
Alarmed, researchers and high-tech industries lobbied Congress to keep the helium flowing. Congress responded: the Responsible Helium Administration and Stewardship Act passed by the House maps out a more orderly shutdown. A similar bill has been introduced to the Senate; if it passes this summer, as is expected, and the law takes effect, the stockpile would be sold to the highest bidders in semi-annual auctions, until just 85 million cubic meters are left. Experts say that point might be reached in 2020, and prices could rise by 50% in that time.
The remaining stock would be available only to government users such as NASA. “The United States will have ceased to be the major player in helium production,” says William Nuttall, an energy expert at the Open University in Milton Keynes, UK. Users will increasingly depend on helium from gas fields in Qatar, Algeria and Russia.
The Russian energy giant Gazprom aims to capture the lion’s share of the market. Last year, the global business consultancy Ernst & Young, based in London, estimated that gas fields in eastern Siberia could produce 250 million cubic meters of crude helium per year by 2030, satisfying at least three-quarters of projected demand. One of the most promising resources is the Chayandinskoye natural-gas field, which contains a relatively rich bounty of about 0.5% helium. In the past six months, Gazprom has signed cooperation agreements with many of the leading companies that purify and supply helium, including Air Liquide, Linde and Matheson. Helium could start to flow from Chayandinskoye by 2018.
In Qatar, extra helium-production capacity is scheduled to come online this year. The Ras Laffan Helium 2 plant could enable the country to meet up to 25% of global helium demand — although much of its output will head east to serve the growing Asian market, says Clarke.
And private efforts in the United States seem to be ramping up. In March, Flatirons Resources of Denver, Colorado, received approval from the US Bureau of Land Management to develop a small well designed to tap helium from a Utah natural-gas field — the first US well devoted solely to helium.
Helium may not run short, but the price increases will hurt labs, says Jodi Lieberman, senior government-relations specialist at the American Physical Society, headquartered in College Park, Maryland. Some low-temperature physicists already spend up to 70% of their grants on the gas, she adds.
In a 2010 report, Selling the Nation’s Helium Reserve, the US National Academy of Sciences (NAS) recommended that funding agencies help researchers to buy cooling systems that recycle helium, or reduce its consumption. So far, cash-strapped funders have not had the resources to make the expensive equipment widely available, says James Lancaster, NAS study director for the report.
But as prices float skyward, helium-sparing equipment may start to look like a necessity.